Average Rankings in Both Classes 2
Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)
-
- Posts: 6848
- Joined: Thu Aug 31, 2006 10:21 pm
Average Rankings in Both Classes 2
Using LPH, FTP, Hub, PageStat and Ushsho, I averaged the five to get an average ranking in both classes. The Hub only goes to 12 or 13 so the lists will only be slightly over 10 teams. In both classes there are some very close teams.
Class AA
1. Duluth East (1.4)
2. Minnetonka (1.8 )
3. Maple Grove (3.4)
4. Eagan (3.6)
5. Edina (4.4)
6. Eden Prairie (6.4)
7. Moorhead (7.2)
8. Grand Rapids (9.4)
8. Wayzata (9.4)
10. Benilde (10.2)
11. Lakeville S (10.4)
12. Hill-Murray (10.8 )
Class A
1. St Thomas (1.8 )
1. Hermantown (1.8 )
3. Breck (2.4)
4. Duluth Marshall (4.6)
5. Thief River Falls (5)
6. Cathedral (7)
6. Totino-Grace (7)
8. East Grand Forks (7.8 )
9. Lourdes (9.6)
10. Blake (10)
10. Mahtomedi (10)
12. Delano (11)
13. Warroad (13.4)
14. Little Falls (13.8 )
Class AA
1. Duluth East (1.4)
2. Minnetonka (1.8 )
3. Maple Grove (3.4)
4. Eagan (3.6)
5. Edina (4.4)
6. Eden Prairie (6.4)
7. Moorhead (7.2)
8. Grand Rapids (9.4)
8. Wayzata (9.4)
10. Benilde (10.2)
11. Lakeville S (10.4)
12. Hill-Murray (10.8 )
Class A
1. St Thomas (1.8 )
1. Hermantown (1.8 )
3. Breck (2.4)
4. Duluth Marshall (4.6)
5. Thief River Falls (5)
6. Cathedral (7)
6. Totino-Grace (7)
8. East Grand Forks (7.8 )
9. Lourdes (9.6)
10. Blake (10)
10. Mahtomedi (10)
12. Delano (11)
13. Warroad (13.4)
14. Little Falls (13.8 )
Last edited by HShockeywatcher on Fri Feb 10, 2012 9:34 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Average Rankings in Both Classes 2
Not a bad way to do rankings, HS....nice.HShockeywatcher wrote:Using LPH, FTP, Hub, PageStat and Ushsho, I averaged the five to get an average ranking in both classes. The Hub only goes to 12 or 13 so the lists will only be slightly over 10 teams. In both classes there are some very close teams.
Re: Average Rankings in Both Classes 2
Of course you put your alma mater on top, HSHW.HShockeywatcher wrote:Class A
1. St Thomas (1.8 )
1. Hermantown (1.8 )
The Puck
LGW
LGW
Re: Average Rankings in Both Classes 2
By virtue of getting 3 #1's Hermantown should be the #1 even if they average the same # of points.PuckU126 wrote:Of course you put your alma mater on top, HSHW.HShockeywatcher wrote:Class A
1. St Thomas (1.8 )
1. Hermantown (1.8 )
-
- Posts: 6848
- Joined: Thu Aug 31, 2006 10:21 pm
Re: Average Rankings in Both Classes 2
It is a TIE. They're both #1. Look at the number in front of them.elliott70 wrote:By virtue of getting 3 #1's Hermantown should be the #1 even if they average the same # of points.PuckU126 wrote:Of course you put your alma mater on top, HSHW.HShockeywatcher wrote:Class A
1. St Thomas (1.8 )
1. Hermantown (1.8 )
I could say the opposite; by virtue of having no #3 rankings, St Thomas should be ahead. But I'm not; they are tied.
Also, there is more weight on the list from polls.
Re: Average Rankings in Both Classes 2
Or, perhaps you need to go to 3 or 4 significant features; i.e., more decimals.HShockeywatcher wrote:It is a TIE. They're both #1. Look at the number in front of them.elliott70 wrote:By virtue of getting 3 #1's Hermantown should be the #1 even if they average the same # of points.PuckU126 wrote:Of course you put your alma mater on top, HSHW.HShockeywatcher wrote:Class A
1. St Thomas (1.8 )
1. Hermantown (1.8 )
I could say the opposite; by virtue of having no #3 rankings, St Thomas should be ahead. But I'm not; they are tied.
Also, there is more weight on the list from polls.
Oh oh HShockeywatcher, you got Teak involved in your quest and that sometimes spells trouble.
Here is what I came up with, using the five polls that you listed:
LPH+FTP+HH+PS+USHSO= Total / 5
Herm 1+1+1+3+1 = 7 / 5 = 1.4
StTA 2+2+2+1+2 = 9 / 5 = 1.8
It looks like Hermantown comes out on top with an average of 1.4, and STA is second with 1.8. Are the above numbers the ones that you used?
Because the PageStat rankings are combined with the AA schools, I put STA at 1, Breck at 2, and Hermantown at 3 as they are the top three A schools in their ranking, in that order.
Here is what I came up with, using the five polls that you listed:
LPH+FTP+HH+PS+USHSO= Total / 5
Herm 1+1+1+3+1 = 7 / 5 = 1.4
StTA 2+2+2+1+2 = 9 / 5 = 1.8
It looks like Hermantown comes out on top with an average of 1.4, and STA is second with 1.8. Are the above numbers the ones that you used?
Because the PageStat rankings are combined with the AA schools, I put STA at 1, Breck at 2, and Hermantown at 3 as they are the top three A schools in their ranking, in that order.
Re: Average Rankings in Both Classes 2
HSHW, you just can’t stand it that there is a small public school ahead of your private STA alma mater.PuckU126 wrote:Of course you put your alma mater on top, HSHW.HShockeywatcher wrote:Class A
1. St Thomas (1.8 )
1. Hermantown (1.8 )
How much would you pay me if I secretly file all the Hawk’s skates before their game on Saturday?
I could make a special trip down to H-town.
Maybe they would lose then and you could put your team back at #1 in your rankings!
-
- Posts: 6848
- Joined: Thu Aug 31, 2006 10:21 pm
Not sure what you are looking at, but this is the page (which is linked from PageStat):Teak wrote:Oh oh HShockeywatcher, you got Teak involved in your quest and that sometimes spells trouble.
Here is what I came up with, using the five polls that you listed:
LPH+FTP+HH+PS+USHSO= Total / 5
Herm 1+1+1+3+1 = 7 / 5 = 1.4
StTA 2+2+2+1+2 = 9 / 5 = 1.8
It looks like Hermantown comes out on top with an average of 1.4, and STA is second with 1.8. Are the above numbers the ones that you used?
Because the PageStat rankings are combined with the AA schools, I put STA at 1, Breck at 2, and Hermantown at 3 as they are the top three A schools in their ranking, in that order.
http://www.ushsho.com/mnrank.htm
Breck is 1st in there, St Thomas 2nd and Hermantown 3rd.
This has nothing to do with any specific school. It is a way to instead saying "X school is ranked Yth in state because Z poll says so" to use the 5 best ranking systems we have in the state and average them. That's all. I started doing it last year, I did it about 3 or 4 weeks ago and I will again in a week or two.blacklung wrote:HSHW, you just can’t stand it that there is a small public school ahead of your private STA alma mater.PuckU126 wrote:Of course you put your alma mater on top, HSHW.HShockeywatcher wrote:Class A
1. St Thomas (1.8 )
1. Hermantown (1.8 )
How much would you pay me if I secretly file all the Hawk’s skates before their game on Saturday?
I could make a special trip down to H-town.
Maybe they would lose then and you could put your team back at #1 in your rankings!
It's funny that no one has an issue with Grand Rapids, Cathedral or Blake being listed after the teams they're TIED with. I didn't make up any numbers, I just added, divided, and listed the teams. I have no hidden agenda, just getting more information out there.
There is no such thing as best...HShockeywatcher wrote:Not sure what you are looking at, but this is the page (which is linked from PageStat):Teak wrote:Oh oh HShockeywatcher, you got Teak involved in your quest and that sometimes spells trouble.
Here is what I came up with, using the five polls that you listed:
LPH+FTP+HH+PS+USHSO= Total / 5
Herm 1+1+1+3+1 = 7 / 5 = 1.4
StTA 2+2+2+1+2 = 9 / 5 = 1.8
It looks like Hermantown comes out on top with an average of 1.4, and STA is second with 1.8. Are the above numbers the ones that you used?
Because the PageStat rankings are combined with the AA schools, I put STA at 1, Breck at 2, and Hermantown at 3 as they are the top three A schools in their ranking, in that order.
http://www.ushsho.com/mnrank.htm
Breck is 1st in there, St Thomas 2nd and Hermantown 3rd.
This has nothing to do with any specific school. It is a way to instead saying "X school is ranked Yth in state because Z poll says so" to use the 5 best ranking systems we have in the state and average them. That's all. I started doing it last year, I did it about 3 or 4 weeks ago and I will again in a week or two.blacklung wrote:HSHW, you just can’t stand it that there is a small public school ahead of your private STA alma mater.PuckU126 wrote:Of course you put your alma mater on top, HSHW.HShockeywatcher wrote:Class A
1. St Thomas (1.8 )
1. Hermantown (1.8 )
How much would you pay me if I secretly file all the Hawk’s skates before their game on Saturday?
I could make a special trip down to H-town.
Maybe they would lose then and you could put your team back at #1 in your rankings!
It's funny that no one has an issue with Grand Rapids, Cathedral or Blake being listed after the teams they're TIED with. I didn't make up any numbers, I just added, divided, and listed the teams. I have no hidden agenda, just getting more information out there.
each prove to be wrong, week in and week out.
Who says no one has an issue with it...
the point is you have a built -in bias, we accept that, but you keep coming back with what ever works for you to get STA at the top of the heap...
most 'people' do not believe that...
-
- Posts: 6848
- Joined: Thu Aug 31, 2006 10:21 pm
Okay, sorry. Substitute "best" with "most credible" or whatever adjective you'd like to use.elliott70 wrote: There is no such thing as best...
each prove to be wrong, week in and week out.
Who says no one has an issue with it...
the point is you have a built -in bias, we accept that, but you keep coming back with what ever works for you to get STA at the top of the heap...
most 'people' do not believe that...
Not sure how a poll based on what has happened in the past can prove to be "wrong" in the future, but you're welcome to your opinion.
I took 30 seconds and made all the ties listed alphabetical, instead of what they were. That better?
You are welcome to "believe" whatever you want. I am a guy who likes numbers and high school hockey. That is all. I am truly sorry if I have offended anyone by finding some averages and making a list.
-
- Posts: 2245
- Joined: Sun Mar 04, 2007 8:41 am
- Location: Orange County, California
- Contact:
Yes, that is much better.HShockeywatcher wrote:Okay, sorry. Substitute "best" with "most credible" or whatever adjective you'd like to use.elliott70 wrote: There is no such thing as best...
each prove to be wrong, week in and week out.
Who says no one has an issue with it...
the point is you have a built -in bias, we accept that, but you keep coming back with what ever works for you to get STA at the top of the heap...
most 'people' do not believe that...
Not sure how a poll based on what has happened in the past can prove to be "wrong" in the future, but you're welcome to your opinion.
I took 30 seconds and made all the ties listed alphabetical, instead of what they were. That better?
You are welcome to "believe" whatever you want. I am a guy who likes numbers and high school hockey. That is all. I am truly sorry if I have offended anyone by finding some averages and making a list.
-
- Posts: 6848
- Joined: Thu Aug 31, 2006 10:21 pm