MrBoDangles wrote:OTC, would the Florida tier 1 teams be able to hang with Minnesota's top 20 or 30 Squirt, or PeeWee teams? No reason other than curiosity...... Thanks in advance
Bo:
Tier I in Florida is at best erratic, at worst a mess.
Because we have mostly programs that are the equivalent of a small associations in your area, there's always an urge to get the better players together on one team. Our Tier II rules require that teams have no more than three players from "out-of-area" - defined as going to school within 60 miles of the team's home rink. (We live 41 miles from where my son plays, so drives like that aren't unusual.)
If you have more than three OOA players you can't be Tier II, so Tier I (there's a catch) or "Tournament" or "Rec" (loophole!) is how these teams get registered. You can form teams by drawing from several programs near Fort Lauderdale and around Tampa Bay and not have
any OOA players, so there is a lot of complaining about these rules.
Anyway, the catch with Tier I is that our affiliate would like to see
programs and not just single
teams. To create a team essentially requires tearing apart a few others to land their best players, which goes against everything USA Hockey, Minnesota Hockey, Statewide Amateur Hockey of Florida, and all other ruling bodies want. Creating a
program would mean building up hockey in an area.
Things break down real quick due to geography, just as you see in Minnesota with spring/summer teams. You can live in the wrong place, making it harder to be a part of these Tier I programs.
Presently we have
three Tier I programs, up from two last year.
- Panther Alliance: this is formed by a "merger" of two programs in Broward County, the South Florida Golden Wolves and the Junior Panthers
Everblades AAA: based in the Naples/Fort Myers area, they mostly have players from all over the state (and sometimes outside)
Tampa Bay Lightning Alliance: our state has had the two teams in the South, with nothing in the North where you see weaker Tier II programs. The Gulf Coast Flames '95s won Pee Wee AA Nationals a few years ago...they were awesome. NHL player Brian Bradley has a son that he coaches and had one of the independent teams at AAA. These two joined under the umbrella organization and are Tier I this year. During their tryout, with aspirations of fielding as many as seven teams, they had no more! Special status was given this year to allow the Tier I program with just two teams, because if it was denied they would have thrown some slop together just to have three.
How do we know? Because the other organizations have been forced to field at least three teams and their results have been hit-or-miss. Which is why I'm giving you a back story when getting to the answer of your question. When teams are formed but they aren't really strong, there's just no reason to fly twice a month to Boston, Toronto, Chicago, and Detroit so you can say you played AAA.
Here are our state's best AAA teams:
'95 Flames - now the Tampa Bay Lightning Alliance U16, they should do well on a national level next season
'96 Lightning - Bradley's team also now under Lightning Alliance flag, should go a little over .500 playing against the best teams nationally (Lawton's son used to play on this team)
'98 Everblades AAA - this team has heavy sponsorship from one guy, so much that kids often play for free and they fly kids in from places like Texas and Pennsylvania to hook up for some tournaments...probably will have a national rank in the Top 10 this year?
'00 Lightning - As you know, Squirts are too young for Tier-anything. This is a top-level AAA team. Coaches are NHL players John Tucker and Michel Pivonka, who both have sons on the team. They were ranked #2 nationally last year.
So when you ask how these teams would fare against top association teams, the answer is that it depends. The '99 Everblades AAA isn't any good at all and one of their coaches supposedly bailed. The '01 Lightning have a blueprint like the '00 with Vezina Trophy winner Jim Carey coaching, but they don't have the top players (who stayed in their clubs) and won't be as dominant.
When these things go well, as in the '98 Blades or '00 'ning, the teams would easily hold their own or beat same-aged teams from Edina, Wayzata, White Bear, Woodbury, and anywhere else. Of course, you have to consider how much work it was to put these teams together.
You asked about Top 20 or 30. Once you get past the Top 5 or 10 at Pee Wees the level drops off a good bit. Our AAA or Tier I teams would usually play at that level. I know a disappointing year for the Everblades AAA is when their teams fall to 30 or so nationally versus Top 15. (Those rankings go by straight birth year.)
What everyone should realize regarding Tier I is that the superclubs out of Detroit aren't as super at Squirts. By Bantams these five teams have not only the best players in Michigan, but also some of the best players from the rest of the country. I know some that have gone there to billet for
Bantams.
Minnesota could easily provide enough players to form two or three or five Tier I clubs that would all be among the Top 20 teams nationally. The big question is should they?