Page 3 of 9
KRACH OA ranking and SOS...
Posted: Wed Dec 07, 2011 8:20 am
by ghshockeyfan
I have been asked a couple questions about some highly ranked teams with great records but that have weaker SOS to-date and what this means for their long-term ranking.
As one could guess, as they start to play some higher-ranked opponents, their ranking will become more solid - or well defined, and far less volatile.
Unfortunately, teams often have no control over the bulk of their schedule due to conference play and subsequently don't see many teams ranked in the top 20, or even half, in the state. These teams are often Class A teams, with few exceptions.
Also, some coaches that do have schedule control sometimes prefer to player a weaker early-season NC schedule and this is simply a matter of preference. I think the notion here is that it can build confidence - especially with younger teams. I don't agree with this approach, but that's just my preference.
Note that this doesn't mean that these teams won't be highly-ranked all year. It simply means that they have to prove it against some higher-ranked opponents to justify this high-ranking to KRACH.
Most obvious of these teams include (from the top 35 overall - in order from weakest to strongest SOS to-date):
TEAM - OA RK - RECORD - SOS RK - SOS AVG - CL - SEC
Dodge County - 16 - 5-0-0 - 112 - 88.4 - AA - 1
Orono - 14 - 5-0-0 - 105 - 83.400 - A - 5
Mankato East/Loyola - 33 - 5-1-0 - 101 82.000 - A - 2
Mound-Westonka - 9 - 7-0-0 - 94 - 77.000 - A - 2
Thief River Falls - 15 - 6-0-1 - 92 - 76.429 - A - 8
Chisago Lakes Area - 35 - 6-2-0 - 89 - 75.250 - A - 7
Mahtomedi - 23 - 5-1-0 - 84 - 72.333 - A - 4
Moorhead - 24 - 4-1-0 - 80 - 70.000 - AA - 8
Red Wing - 31 - 5-2-0 - 73 - 65.857 - A - 1
Other teams right on the edge of this same scenario - to-date - are:
Hopkins
Hutchinson
South St. Paul
Apple Valley
Rogers
Wayzata
Irondale
White Bear Lake
Stillwater
Eagan
It will be interesting to follow these teams over time and see how it all plays out.
Good luck to all teams!
OVERALL:
http://www.bgoski.com/KRACH_OA.htm
SOS (Strength-Of-Schedule) is at:
http://www.bgoski.com/KRACH_SOS.htm
Re: Updated 12/07 AM
Posted: Wed Dec 07, 2011 11:04 am
by livin' in the 651
No Score Reported for These Games:
Tue, December 6, 2011
Hutchinson vs. Mankato West
Wayzata vs. Edina
Alexandria vs. Morris/Benson Area
Chaska/Chanhassen vs. Shakopee
Mounds View vs. Cretin-Derham Hall
Park Rapids Area vs. Thief River Falls
Albert Lea vs. Austin
MV 4, CDH 3
Updated 12/07 PM
Posted: Wed Dec 07, 2011 8:09 pm
by ghshockeyfan
Updated 12/07 PM:
No Score Reported for These Games:
Tue, December 6, 2011
Hutchinson vs. Mankato West
Alexandria vs. Morris/Benson Area
Chaska/Chanhassen vs. Shakopee
Park Rapids Area vs. Thief River Falls
Re: Updated 12/07 PM
Posted: Thu Dec 08, 2011 11:46 am
by MNHockeyFan
ghshockeyfan wrote:No Score Reported for These Games:
Tue, December 6, 2011
Hutchinson vs. Mankato West
Alexandria vs. Morris/Benson Area
Chaska/Chanhassen vs. Shakopee
Park Rapids Area vs. Thief River Falls
Hockey Hub shows:
Hutchinson 4, Mankato West 3
Alexandria vs. Morris/Benson Area POSTPONED
Chaska/Chanhassen 3, Shakopee 3
Park Rapids Area 0, Thief River Falls 6 (this game was played on Saturday, November 26th)
Re: Updated 12/07 PM
Posted: Thu Dec 08, 2011 2:58 pm
by ghshockeyfan
MNHockeyFan wrote:ghshockeyfan wrote:No Score Reported for These Games:
Tue, December 6, 2011
Hutchinson vs. Mankato West
Alexandria vs. Morris/Benson Area
Chaska/Chanhassen vs. Shakopee
Park Rapids Area vs. Thief River Falls
Hockey Hub shows:
Hutchinson 4, Mankato West 3
Alexandria vs. Morris/Benson Area POSTPONED
Chaska/Chanhassen 3, Shakopee 3
Park Rapids Area 0, Thief River Falls 6 (this game was played on Saturday, November 26th)
THANKS! I sent this in and we'll wait for an update...
Updated 12/08 4PM
Posted: Thu Dec 08, 2011 4:28 pm
by ghshockeyfan
Updated 12/08 4PM:
No Score Reported for These Games:
NONE!!!
Updated 12/09 AM
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 8:25 am
by ghshockeyfan
Updated 12/09 AM:
No Score Reported for These Games:
Thu, December 8, 2011
Elk River/Zimmerman vs. Eden Prairie
International Falls vs. Lake of the Woods
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 10:16 am
by Tigers33
Those records are all wrong
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 10:29 am
by ghshockeyfan
Tigers33 wrote:Those records are all wrong
example(s)?
Re: Updated 12/09 AM
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 10:29 am
by MNHockeyFan
ghshockeyfan wrote:No Score Reported for These Games:
Thu, December 8, 2011
Elk River/Zimmerman vs. Eden Prairie
International Falls vs. Lake of the Woods
As mentioned in the Big Games thread the Minneapolis paper shows a 5-5 OT Tie between Elk River/Zimmerman and Eden Prairie. It has the box score so it's probably legit.
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 11:43 am
by Tigers33
GHS -
Look at your scores in the SOS list and compare those to your AA and A rankings. The records dont match up. I believe the strength of schedule has it correct and the records in the AA/A are inaccurate.
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 12:01 pm
by ghshockeyfan
Tigers33 wrote:GHS -
Look at your scores in the SOS list and compare those to your AA and A rankings. The records dont match up. I believe the strength of schedule has it correct and the records in the AA/A are inaccurate.
I'll take a look now - thanks for the heads-up!
Re: Updated 12/09 AM
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 12:03 pm
by ghshockeyfan
MNHockeyFan wrote:ghshockeyfan wrote:No Score Reported for These Games:
Thu, December 8, 2011
Elk River/Zimmerman vs. Eden Prairie
International Falls vs. Lake of the Woods
As mentioned in the Big Games thread the Minneapolis paper shows a 5-5 OT Tie between Elk River/Zimmerman and Eden Prairie. It has the box score so it's probably legit.
Looks like MN Scores is going with the 5-5 T as well.
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 12:32 pm
by ghshockeyfan
ghshockeyfan wrote:Tigers33 wrote:GHS -
Look at your scores in the SOS list and compare those to your AA and A rankings. The records dont match up. I believe the strength of schedule has it correct and the records in the AA/A are inaccurate.
I'll take a look now - thanks for the heads-up!
Hmm.. I took a quick - and I mean quick - look and all the records in the five ranking types match-up. I also compared to MN Scores records and the only differences I saw were for teams with Non-MN MSHSL opponents (expected since KRACH doesn't count those games).
I'm going to re-run and re-post as there could have been an issue with the posting and something getting out-of-sync. Plus the EP/ER game is in now so that is another reason to re-run.
Updated 12/09 NOON
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 1:15 pm
by ghshockeyfan
Updated 12/09 NOON:
No Score Reported for These Games:
NONE!!!
Updated 12/10 NOON
Posted: Sat Dec 10, 2011 12:41 pm
by ghshockeyfan
Updated 12/10 NOON:
No Score Reported for These Games:
Fri, December 9, 2011
Litchfield/Dassel-Cokato vs. Hutchinson
Updated 12/11 NOON
Posted: Sun Dec 11, 2011 11:04 am
by ghshockeyfan
Updated 12/11 NOON:
No Score Reported for These Games:
Sat, December 10, 2011
Park Rapids Area vs. Eveleth-Gilbert
Burnsville 5 vs. Rosemount 5 - just not posted yet
Coon Rapids vs. Anoka
Willmar vs. St. Peter/L-H/M-L
Updated 12/11 PM
Posted: Sun Dec 11, 2011 9:40 pm
by ghshockeyfan
Updated 12/11 PM:
No Score Reported for These Games:
Sat, December 10, 2011
Park Rapids Area vs. Eveleth-Gilbert
Willmar vs. St. Peter/L-H/M-L
Updated 12/12 5PM
Posted: Mon Dec 12, 2011 5:43 pm
by ghshockeyfan
Updated 12/12 5PM:
No Score Reported for These Games:
NONE!!!
Updated 12/13 AM
Posted: Tue Dec 13, 2011 1:44 am
by ghshockeyfan
Updated 12/13 AM:
No Score Reported for These Games:
NONE!!!
Updated 12/14 AM
Posted: Wed Dec 14, 2011 10:19 am
by ghshockeyfan
Updated 12/14 AM:
No Score Reported for These Games:
Tue, December 13, 2011
LPGE/WDC vs. Morris/Benson Area
North Metro 0 vs. Maple Grove 6 - just not updated yet
Willmar vs. Alexandria
St. Cloud vs. River Lakes
Austin vs. Northfield
South St. Paul 4 vs. Henry Sibley 1 - just not updated yet
Forest Lake vs. East Ridge
Updated 12/14 5PM
Posted: Wed Dec 14, 2011 6:44 pm
by ghshockeyfan
Updated 12/14 5PM:
No Score Reported for These Games:
NONE!!!
Tue, December 13, 2011
LPGE/WDC 6 vs. Morris/Benson Area 2 - just not updated yet
Forest Lake 2 vs. East Ridge 2 - just not updated yet
Posted: Wed Dec 14, 2011 7:36 pm
by cdhparent
Whoever runs the power rankings has the CDH record wrong. CDH is 7-3-1, not 6-4-1.
Wins = No. St. Paul, Shakopee, St. Paul United, Woodbury, Simley, East Ridge, Hastings.
Losses = WBL, Roseville, Mounds View.
Tie = Eagan.
Posted: Wed Dec 14, 2011 7:50 pm
by ghshockeyfan
cdhparent wrote:Whoever runs the power rankings has the CDH record wrong. CDH is 7-3-1, not 6-4-1.
Wins = No. St. Paul, Shakopee, St. Paul United, Woodbury, Simley, East Ridge, Hastings.
Losses = WBL, Roseville, Mounds View.
Tie = Eagan.
I'll look into it. Must be an issue with a score inversion. Thanks for the heads-up!
Posted: Wed Dec 14, 2011 7:57 pm
by ghshockeyfan
ghshockeyfan wrote:cdhparent wrote:Whoever runs the power rankings has the CDH record wrong. CDH is 7-3-1, not 6-4-1.
Wins = No. St. Paul, Shakopee, St. Paul United, Woodbury, Simley, East Ridge, Hastings.
Losses = WBL, Roseville, Mounds View.
Tie = Eagan.
I'll look into it. Must be an issue with a score inversion. Thanks for the heads-up!
I'm guessing the first score in the list below is inverted based on the list you provided and what is on the HUB:
http://www.mngirlshockeyhub.com/schedul ... ason=49295
I'm asking that MN Scores correct this:
CDH:
http://www.minnesota-scores.net/teamsch ... 0&tid=2201
DATE TIME VS RESULT SCORE F=Final
Tue, Nov 15 7:30 PM vs. North St. Paul
L 7-2 F
Thu, Nov 17 7:00 PM at Shakopee W 11-7 F
Sat, Nov 19 2:00 PM vs. St. Paul United W 3-2 F
Tue, Nov 22 7:30 PM vs. White Bear Lake L 2-1 F
Tue, Nov 29 7:30 PM at Woodbury W 3-0 F
Thu, Dec 1 7:30 PM vs. Eagan T 2-2 F/OT
Sat, Dec 3 7:30 PM at Roseville L 4-0 F
Tue, Dec 6 7:30 PM vs. Mounds View L 4-3 F
Thu, Dec 8 7:30 PM at Simley W 4-2 F
Sat, Dec 10 7:30 PM vs. East Ridge W 2-0 F
Tue, Dec 13 7:30 PM at Hastings W 4-2 F
This will impact KRACH & QRF as they draw from the same results but are different ranking algorithms.