Page 1 of 3

bantam A - preseason top 5

Posted: Thu Sep 03, 2009 11:35 am
by puckboy
lets have em-

here is mine
Wayzata
EP
Edina
MKTA
DE

Re: bantam A - preseason top 5

Posted: Thu Sep 03, 2009 1:31 pm
by Nobodyonya
puckboy wrote:lets have em-

here is mine
Wayzata
EP
Edina
MKTA
DE
Since this thread is about naming the top teams expand on why you believe they should be there

Posted: Thu Sep 03, 2009 1:33 pm
by observer
The 4 largest associations in the state and one from up north.

Re: bantam A - preseason top 5

Posted: Thu Sep 03, 2009 1:34 pm
by muckandgrind
Nobodyonya wrote:
puckboy wrote:lets have em-

here is mine
Wayzata
EP
Edina
MKTA
DE
Since this thread is about naming the top teams expand on why you believe they should be there
The easiest answer to that question is that you generally see these same 5 or 6 teams competing for the State title EVERY year.

Posted: Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:11 pm
by MaxSnatch
Top 5 is easy

Try the next 5 or 10!!!

Oh yeah...you may have wanted to include Edina??

Posted: Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:36 pm
by muckandgrind
MaxSnatch wrote:Top 5 is easy

Try the next 5 or 10!!!

Oh yeah...you may have wanted to include Edina??
He did.... :wink:

Re: bantam A - preseason top 5

Posted: Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:44 pm
by Nobodyonya
muckandgrind wrote:
Nobodyonya wrote:
puckboy wrote:lets have em-

here is mine
Wayzata
EP
Edina
MKTA
DE
Since this thread is about naming the top teams expand on why you believe they should be there
The easiest answer to that question is that you generally see these same 5 or 6 teams competing for the State title EVERY year.


It may be the easiest answer, but not necessarily the correct answer. Since 2001 Centennial played in the State Championship game 6 times, Wayzata, Eden Prairie,Edina, Wayzata and W.B.L. all 2 times. I agree with Max the next 5 teams would be much tougher to pick.

Re: bantam A - preseason top 5

Posted: Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:51 pm
by Chuck Norris Fan
Nobodyonya wrote:
It may be the easiest answer, but not necessarily the correct answer. Since 2001 Centennial played in the State Championship game 6 times, Wayzata, Eden Prairie,Edina, Wayzata and W.B.L. all 2 times. I agree with Max the next 5 teams would be much tougher to pick.
Centennial will be young this year, and the coaching staff has changed hands, and they weren't very good as peewees... i wouldn't be surprised if they miss the tourney again this year.

Re: bantam A - preseason top 5

Posted: Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:52 pm
by muckandgrind
Nobodyonya wrote:
muckandgrind wrote:
Nobodyonya wrote: Since this thread is about naming the top teams expand on why you believe they should be there
The easiest answer to that question is that you generally see these same 5 or 6 teams competing for the State title EVERY year.


It may be the easiest answer, but not necessarily the correct answer. Since 2001 Centennial played in the State Championship game 6 times, Wayzata, Eden Prairie,Edina, Wayzata and W.B.L. all 2 times. I agree with Max the next 5 teams would be much tougher to pick.
The question wasn't which two teams do you expect to play in the championships, but what are the top 5 teams. While you're right that that group of teams may not have been in the final game, they are GENERALLY always included in that top 5 discussion. Another indicator is to go back to years to see how this kids did when they were A PeeWees...although, you also need to be aware that some of the best 9th graders may leave those Bantam teams to play HS.

Re: bantam A - preseason top 5

Posted: Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:06 pm
by Chuck Norris Fan
muckandgrind wrote:PeeWees...although, you also need to be aware that some of the best 9th graders may leave those Bantam teams to play HS.
do you know any?

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2009 9:48 am
by love2skate
i would agree. you definitely have to put edina, ep, wayzata, and DE in there but who comes next?

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2009 10:02 am
by D10RoXyourSoX
Duluth East will be asked to the prom again! They have a very good staff that gets the pick of the area, kids/parents want to play for them. Look for Elk River...one word- TOUGH!

So my pick DE vs LOSER!

DE defeating LOSER 5-1

Re: bantam A - preseason top 5

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2009 10:09 am
by muckandgrind
Chuck Norris Fan wrote:
muckandgrind wrote:PeeWees...although, you also need to be aware that some of the best 9th graders may leave those Bantam teams to play HS.
do you know any?
Don't for for a fact, but I've heard there might be a few....Will Besse be back at Wayzata?

Re: bantam A - preseason top 5

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2009 10:46 am
by mngopherfan
muckandgrind wrote:
Chuck Norris Fan wrote:
muckandgrind wrote:PeeWees...although, you also need to be aware that some of the best 9th graders may leave those Bantam teams to play HS.
do you know any?
Don't for for a fact, but I've heard there might be a few....Will Besse be back at Wayzata?
I heard besse is playing Varsity at Benilde...

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2009 12:47 pm
by Chuck Norris Fan
Obviously this is just a preliminary list, and a lot depends on who is going to loose kids to HS. So don't hang me yet, lets revisit this in October.


1 Edina
2 Wayzata
3 Woodbury
4 Eden Prairie
5 Eagan
6 Lakeville South
7 Duluth East
8 Apple Valley
9 Grand Rapids
10 Maple Grove
11 Cloquet
12 Minnetonka
13 Roseau
14 Elk River
15 White Bear Lake
16 Chaska
17 Burnsville
18 Bloomington Jefferson
19 Lakeville North
20 Coon Rapids

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2009 1:07 pm
by observer
"I heard besse is playing Varsity at Benilde..."

Ah, dad, you might want to wait for tryouts.

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2009 1:13 pm
by muckandgrind
observer wrote:"I heard besse is playing Varsity at Benilde..."

Ah, dad, you might want to wait for tryouts.
I don't think "dad" has anything to do with it...I could easily see Besse step into virtually any varsity roster this season. Let me put it this way, if Besse is back at Wayzata, it's because he wants to be back.

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2009 1:40 pm
by mngopherfan
observer wrote:"I heard besse is playing Varsity at Benilde..."

Ah, dad, you might want to wait for tryouts.
Right, I'm Besse's dad. You've got me pegged.

Like Muck said, the only way he'll be at the Bantam level is if he wants to...he'll be able to play in the top 3 lines at BSM.

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2009 2:51 pm
by TTpuckster
Looks pretty good though, CNF.

You might want to sneak EGF in there somewhere. They were in the state tourney last year in PeeWees and had both their A and B team in the state tourney for PeeWees this year.

Chuck Norris Fan wrote:Obviously this is just a preliminary list, and a lot depends on who is going to loose kids to HS. So don't hang me yet, lets revisit this in October.


1 Edina
2 Wayzata
3 Woodbury
4 Eden Prairie
5 Eagan
6 Lakeville South
7 Duluth East
8 Apple Valley
9 Grand Rapids
10 Maple Grove
11 Cloquet
12 Minnetonka
13 Roseau
14 Elk River
15 White Bear Lake
16 Chaska
17 Burnsville
18 Bloomington Jefferson
19 Lakeville North
20 Coon Rapids

Top 20

Posted: Sun Sep 06, 2009 9:16 am
by northwoods oldtimer
Chuck Norris Fan wrote:Obviously this is just a preliminary list, and a lot depends on who is going to loose kids to HS. So don't hang me yet, lets revisit this in October.


1 Edina
2 Wayzata
3 Woodbury
4 Eden Prairie
5 Eagan
6 Lakeville South
7 Duluth East
8 Apple Valley
9 Grand Rapids
10 Maple Grove
11 Cloquet
12 Minnetonka
13 Roseau
14 Elk River
15 White Bear Lake
16 Chaska
17 Burnsville
18 Bloomington Jefferson
19 Lakeville North
20 Coon Rapids
Chuck do not let the haters keep you from posting your weekly list, you do such a great job of ranking.

Posted: Sun Sep 06, 2009 5:41 pm
by puckulence
Chuck Norris Fan wrote:Obviously this is just a preliminary list, and a lot depends on who is going to loose kids to HS. So don't hang me yet, lets revisit this in October.


1 Edina
2 Wayzata
3 Woodbury
4 Eden Prairie
5 Eagan
6 Lakeville South
7 Duluth East
8 Apple Valley
9 Grand Rapids
10 Maple Grove
11 Cloquet
12 Minnetonka
13 Roseau
14 Elk River
15 White Bear Lake
16 Chaska
17 Burnsville
18 Bloomington Jefferson
19 Lakeville North
20 Coon Rapids
Do you still think Maple Grove will be top 10 with out Jake coaching. I know they have a deep association to pick from but a quality coach (and it being a non-parent coach with no ties to people) can make a difference.

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2009 12:03 pm
by BlackTape
You can probably switch Elk River and Maple Grove in the rankings since Jake is now coaching in Elk River :o

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2009 3:11 pm
by elliott70
Top Ten - North

1 Duluth East
2 Roseau
3 East Grnad Forks
4 Grand Rapids
5 Cloquet
6 Moorhead
7 Brainerd
8 Virginia
9 Hibbing
10 Bemidji

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2009 3:25 pm
by Nobodyonya
elliott70 wrote:Top Ten - North

1 Duluth East
2 Roseau
3 East Grnad Forks
4 Grand Rapids
5 Cloquet
6 Moorhead
7 Brainerd
8 Virginia
9 Hibbing
10 Bemidji
No resentment here :lol:

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2009 3:26 pm
by Nobodyonya
Nobodyonya wrote:
elliott70 wrote:Top Ten - North

1 Duluth East
2 Roseau
3 East Grnad Forks
4 Grand Rapids
5 Cloquet
6 Moorhead
7 Brainerd
8 Virginia
9 Hibbing
10 Bemidji
No resentment here :lol:
My bad, didn't notice the "Top 10 North"