Mercy Rule
Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)
Mercy Rule
After the recent 22-0 win for Virginia against Silver Bay, many people seemed to be upset by such the huge deficit. Do you think there should be a mercy rule enforced? If so, by what score? If not, why?[/img]
-
- Posts: 67
- Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 11:36 pm
-
- Posts: 60
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2010 12:46 pm
Re: Mercy Rule
There already is a mercy rule. If a team is leading by 6 or more goals in the third period there will be running time until the deficit is less than 6 goals.bronx18 wrote:After the recent 22-0 win for Virginia against Silver Bay, many people seemed to be upset by such the huge deficit. Do you think there should be a mercy rule enforced? If so, by what score? If not, why?[/img]
Should that rule be extended to the second period? I.e. If a team is winning by 8 goals in the second should the clock start running?
We're here. We're there. We're everywhere.
Re: Mercy Rule
That would be a great idea. But never, ever call the game...TuckerMax93 wrote:There already is a mercy rule. If a team is leading by 6 or more goals in the third period there will be running time until the deficit is less than 6 goals.bronx18 wrote:After the recent 22-0 win for Virginia against Silver Bay, many people seemed to be upset by such the huge deficit. Do you think there should be a mercy rule enforced? If so, by what score? If not, why?[/img]
Should that rule be extended to the second period? I.e. If a team is winning by 8 goals in the second should the clock start running?
Re: Mercy Rule
No. Leave it as it is. Everyone is human. Everyone will get knocked down. Let the jerks be jerks if they must be jerks.TuckerMax93 wrote:There already is a mercy rule. If a team is leading by 6 or more goals in the third period there will be running time until the deficit is less than 6 goals.bronx18 wrote:After the recent 22-0 win for Virginia against Silver Bay, many people seemed to be upset by such the huge deficit. Do you think there should be a mercy rule enforced? If so, by what score? If not, why?[/img]
Should that rule be extended to the second period? I.e. If a team is winning by 8 goals in the second should the clock start running?
-
- Posts: 255
- Joined: Sat Nov 29, 2008 11:53 pm
Re: Mercy Rule
Let kids play the game. I've never been a fan of the run time rule. And don't try to pull the "its embarrassing for the losing team and they just want the game to be over." i've been on that side before all the way up to bantams and honestly i just wanted to play the game. at a certain point it doesnt become about the scorebord, i would just go out there and try to win the battle because at least i could be proud about that. As soon as you get to run time it just feels worse because it says you aren't worth the full time to play the entire game. In my opinion thats more degrading than the final score.TuckerMax93 wrote:There already is a mercy rule. If a team is leading by 6 or more goals in the third period there will be running time until the deficit is less than 6 goals.bronx18 wrote:After the recent 22-0 win for Virginia against Silver Bay, many people seemed to be upset by such the huge deficit. Do you think there should be a mercy rule enforced? If so, by what score? If not, why?[/img]
Should that rule be extended to the second period? I.e. If a team is winning by 8 goals in the second should the clock start running?
-
- Posts: 68
- Joined: Mon Dec 28, 2009 11:59 pm
-
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Wed Feb 11, 2009 11:46 pm
- Location: U of M
I played varsity baseball and hockey, and I am in favor of a mercy rule for hockey. If a team is up by 10 going into the third period, or goes up by 10 in the third period, call the game. That way your guaranteed two periods of play.
Obviously the reason for the 10-run rule in baseball is because baseball games don't have a time constraint. a 21-out game could last 4 hours without a mercy rule.
Obviously the reason for the 10-run rule in baseball is because baseball games don't have a time constraint. a 21-out game could last 4 hours without a mercy rule.
Imagine a world...with no Wisconsin
I think this idea may actually workDotaDangler wrote:I played varsity baseball and hockey, and I am in favor of a mercy rule for hockey. If a team is up by 10 going into the third period, or goes up by 10 in the third period, call the game. That way your guaranteed two periods of play.
Obviously the reason for the 10-run rule in baseball is because baseball games don't have a time constraint. a 21-out game could last 4 hours without a mercy rule.
-
- Posts: 29
- Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2010 2:54 pm
-
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Tue Mar 02, 2010 11:25 pm
-
- Posts: 45
- Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2010 3:58 pm
-
- Posts: 36
- Joined: Tue Dec 29, 2009 4:17 pm
-
- Posts: 6848
- Joined: Thu Aug 31, 2006 10:21 pm
Re: Mercy Rule
I have seen so many situations like this. In sub-varsity basketball games refs will often ask the coach of the losing team if they can just play running time. It's pretty insulting to the kids who are there because they want to play.hawkhockey wrote:Let kids play the game. I've never been a fan of the run time rule. And don't try to pull the "its embarrassing for the losing team and they just want the game to be over." i've been on that side before all the way up to bantams and honestly i just wanted to play the game. at a certain point it doesnt become about the scorebord, i would just go out there and try to win the battle because at least i could be proud about that. As soon as you get to run time it just feels worse because it says you aren't worth the full time to play the entire game. In my opinion thats more degrading than the final score.TuckerMax93 wrote:There already is a mercy rule. If a team is leading by 6 or more goals in the third period there will be running time until the deficit is less than 6 goals.bronx18 wrote:After the recent 22-0 win for Virginia against Silver Bay, many people seemed to be upset by such the huge deficit. Do you think there should be a mercy rule enforced? If so, by what score? If not, why?[/img]
Should that rule be extended to the second period? I.e. If a team is winning by 8 goals in the second should the clock start running?
mulefarm wrote:Baseball and softball have a run rule, but does any other high school sport have a mercy rule? I've seen some basketball and wrestling scores that are equivilant to the 22-0 score.
HockeyMN1 basically said what I was going to say. A game with an amazing baseball team playing a team that sucks could theoretically never end as there is no clock. It is unfortunate to do, but that's the situation.HockeyMN1 wrote:Well in baseball games there is no time limit so they kinda have to put a stop to it at some point. The 10 run rule in baseball is pretty fair but it wouldn't work in hockey.
Terrible idea to end a game early, it it was up to me i'd get rid of the running time as well. What is the biggest perceived problem with MN HS Hockey? Kids leaving early to play juniors or NTDP. Why do they do it? To get more games is a big reason. Now we don't even want to let the kids finish the measly 25 games they get? Horrible idea.
-
- Posts: 362
- Joined: Wed Feb 17, 2010 10:50 am
- Location: victory lane