Posted: Sat Dec 14, 2013 9:25 am
Hill may lose in the Schwans tourney, hard to say without knowing who they will face.
Odds are they will lose one or two in January.
Odds are they will lose one or two in January.
The Largest Prep Hockey Message Board Community on the Web
https://www.ushsho.com/forums/
So when a team plays in a tournament with crystal clear rules set in place for a winner and a loser, and one team clearly wins according to the rules, its not a win.hockeydad wrote:Luverne tied STMA today, 1-1. They won the shootout to advance in the tournament, but officially it goes as a tie, so scratch the Cardinals off the list. Also, Eden Prairie lost Dec. 21, and again today
That leaves two
Class AA - Hill Murray 8-0, faces Minnetonka Friday
Class A - Mankato West 10-0, faces Appleton East (WI) Friday
It is a widely accepted fact that all tournament shootout wins are considered ties, and in fact are officially considered a tie by the MSHSL. The shootout is only allowed to advance a winner for the sake of the tournament bracket, not for win/loss records.notTONIGHT wrote:So when a team plays in a tournament with crystal clear rules set in place for a winner and a loser, and one team clearly wins according to the rules, its not a win.hockeydad wrote:Luverne tied STMA today, 1-1. They won the shootout to advance in the tournament, but officially it goes as a tie, so scratch the Cardinals off the list. Also, Eden Prairie lost Dec. 21, and again today
That leaves two
Class AA - Hill Murray 8-0, faces Minnetonka Friday
Class A - Mankato West 10-0, faces Appleton East (WI) Friday
Understood.......
A team that knows what is expected of it, completes expectations, ends up with negative notch on its record.PuckRanger wrote:It is a widely accepted fact that all tournament shootout wins are considered ties, and in fact are officially considered a tie by the MSHSL. The shootout is only allowed to advance a winner for the sake of the tournament bracket, not for win/loss records.notTONIGHT wrote:So when a team plays in a tournament with crystal clear rules set in place for a winner and a loser, and one team clearly wins according to the rules, its not a win.hockeydad wrote:Luverne tied STMA today, 1-1. They won the shootout to advance in the tournament, but officially it goes as a tie, so scratch the Cardinals off the list. Also, Eden Prairie lost Dec. 21, and again today
That leaves two
Class AA - Hill Murray 8-0, faces Minnetonka Friday
Class A - Mankato West 10-0, faces Appleton East (WI) Friday
Understood.......
Unfortunate... maybe. But this is not a new thing - its been around for ages - both teams and coaches were well aware of this, so they really did not complete expectations if their goal was to post a "W" on their record.notTONIGHT wrote:A team that knows what is expected of it, completes expectations, ends up with negative notch on its record.PuckRanger wrote:It is a widely accepted fact that all tournament shootout wins are considered ties, and in fact are officially considered a tie by the MSHSL. The shootout is only allowed to advance a winner for the sake of the tournament bracket, not for win/loss records.notTONIGHT wrote: So when a team plays in a tournament with crystal clear rules set in place for a winner and a loser, and one team clearly wins according to the rules, its not a win.
Understood.......
Universally accepted or not. Unfortunate.
andovercw wrote:Stop whining NotTonight! Everyone knows, including you, it goes down as a tie. I watched your cards and have to say I wasn't too impressed. They play a middle of the road cities team and couldn't do anything offensively. 1 player stood out and that was your defenseman 22. He didn't lack much and made up what he did with swag.
How is a tie negative?notTONIGHT wrote:A team that knows what is expected of it, completes expectations, ends up with negative notch on its record.
Universally accepted or not. Unfortunate.
The saying goes, a tie is like kissing your sister. Traxler.... you must have a pretty good looking sisterTraxler wrote:How is a tie negative?notTONIGHT wrote:A team that knows what is expected of it, completes expectations, ends up with negative notch on its record.
Universally accepted or not. Unfortunate.