Doglover wrote:Doesn't Edina now go from 2 of the best line to one - granted THE best line in the state, but wise for the long term? Isn't it easier to beat a team with only one strong line or are they strong enough to stop all competitors? Didn't see them play but I'm sure they are a force!! Can't imagine how amazing they would be two lines deep with the amazing Budish.
It's an interesting question, and one that was debated quite a bit last year as well as this year.
Last year, I didn't really like the Lee-Budish-Everson line, which is what they were going with by the state tournament. I thought they were deep enough to spread them out and have two quality lines. To me, Edina looked better when they had two lines flying around causing problems, as they did in their win over East (with the Lee-Budish-Everson line being the PP line), than they did at State, when they seemed to be relying on one line for all the scoring.
This year, without Budish, though, I feel they're better off loading up with Everson-Lee-Gaarder. Though they have some intriguing options with Sit, Eppel, Taft, etc., I think they are better served with one solid line that's been together for some time now. The early returns suggest that as well; the Schwan Cup should give us a clearer picture.