Roseau or Edina? Whos the best?

Older Topics, Not the current discussion

Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)

Who is the cream of the crop?

Roseau Rams
115
66%
Edina hornets
59
34%
 
Total votes: 174

The Huge Hook
Posts: 221
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2008 10:10 am
Location: South of Hwy. 2

Post by The Huge Hook »

packerboy wrote:
grindiangrad-80 wrote: When Edina wins it's because they are the best. When Edina loses it's because they "looked past" somebody. GR is 3-2 all-time vs Edina in the state tournament.
Good teams don't "look past" anyone in March.
SSP has a good record against Edina in the tournament too.
Oh, don't go there!!!!! I'm having flashbacks. 8)
mnpuck31
Posts: 6
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2008 5:46 pm

Post by mnpuck31 »

cmon I believe benilde could be considered the best, especially with the determination and heart they have, but it is to bad tonka could not make it as well as a wild card, since section 1AA is pretty weak with one of the lakeville teams going to state.

Look out for the Red Knights!!
Cornbread
Posts: 191
Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 9:53 pm

Post by Cornbread »

The Huge Hook wrote:
61ache wrote:
Cornbread wrote:Go Burnsville...........#1
Please, please don't say Roseau #1 (I think you may be the kiss of death to a team)
Come on Corn........Do it!!!!!! =D> =D>
Go Centennial and Lakeville..............#1
The Huge Hook
Posts: 221
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2008 10:10 am
Location: South of Hwy. 2

Post by The Huge Hook »

Cornbread wrote:
The Huge Hook wrote:
61ache wrote: Please, please don't say Roseau #1 (I think you may be the kiss of death to a team)
Come on Corn........Do it!!!!!! =D> =D>
Go Centennial and Lakeville..............#1
What about Roseau???? Do it.
wildhockey5
Posts: 12
Joined: Sat Feb 23, 2008 1:15 pm

wont happen.

Post by wildhockey5 »

I dont no if the citys teams can beat the roseau rams
Hock-ey- One of the best sports in the world.
Nostalgic Nerd
Posts: 1366
Joined: Thu Mar 11, 2004 7:16 pm
Location: St. Paul, MN

Post by Nostalgic Nerd »

Although the Roseau Rules should be from here on out (via Blaine game):

1. Bill Belichick rule in taking out best player: Ness
2. Points: get shot on goal and charge net for rebounds
3. When close on Lee, shoot high

Easier said than done though.
skiumah
Posts: 146
Joined: Sat Jan 19, 2008 10:21 pm
Location: City of Lakes

Post by skiumah »

The Rams are the defending champs and they haven't lost this season. Until someone beats them, they're the best.

I don't think Edina can win it all with that goal tending displayed last night. Maybe that was just an off night??
hockeywatcher4
Posts: 164
Joined: Mon Feb 25, 2008 9:12 pm

Post by hockeywatcher4 »

skiumah wrote:The Rams are the defending champs and they haven't lost this season. Until someone beats them, they're the best.

I don't think Edina can win it all with that goal tending displayed last night. Maybe that was just an off night??

No cashetta isnt that good of goalie, he has to play the 3 of the best games of his life for them to stand a chance
Doc Holliday
Posts: 657
Joined: Thu Oct 12, 2006 3:20 pm
Location: SW Suburbs

Post by Doc Holliday »

hockeywatcher4 wrote:

No cashetta isnt that good of goalie, he has to play the 3 of the best games of his life for them to stand a chance
Perhaps I watched a different game, but I saw one bad goal & two that were not his fault and would probably have been put past any other goalie in the state.
watchdog
Posts: 886
Joined: Wed Jan 10, 2007 8:54 am
Location: weak hockey country

Post by watchdog »

isnt he going to und?????
O-townClown
Posts: 4422
Joined: Wed Oct 10, 2007 12:22 pm
Location: Typical homeboy from the O-Town

yup

Post by O-townClown »

Doc Holliday wrote:
Perhaps I watched a different game, but I saw one bad goal & two that were not his fault and would probably have been put past any other goalie in the state.
Doc, you saw it right. I just watched the highlights. For some reason he didn't cover the post on the first one and the wide angle shot went in. After that he was fine.
Be kind. Rewind.
sticksuphigh
Posts: 116
Joined: Tue Nov 27, 2007 11:18 am

Post by sticksuphigh »

Doc Holliday wrote:
hockeywatcher4 wrote:

No cashetta isnt that good of goalie, he has to play the 3 of the best games of his life for them to stand a chance
Perhaps I watched a different game, but I saw one bad goal & two that were not his fault and would probably have been put past any other goalie in the state.
Considering he had one of the top GAA in the Metro, I would say he was at least "good", or Edina's defense is "decent", but since no one thinks either of these areas are worth mentioning for Edina, I am confused.

The thing Cashetta is able to do, is to recover from a bad goal, and finish the game strong. This aspect alone will give the Hornets a chance to advance deep next week.

M. Lee is one tender who seems to be on auto pilot with his consistency, but with the hornets averaging over 50 SOG during sections, the law of averages may favor the Hornets in such a match-up. Just a thought..
OGEE OGELTHORPE
Posts: 703
Joined: Sun Sep 30, 2007 9:44 pm
Location: State of shock/without the awe

Post by OGEE OGELTHORPE »

sticksuphigh wrote:
Doc Holliday wrote:
hockeywatcher4 wrote:

No cashetta isnt that good of goalie, he has to play the 3 of the best games of his life for them to stand a chance
Perhaps I watched a different game, but I saw one bad goal & two that were not his fault and would probably have been put past any other goalie in the state.
Considering he had one of the top GAA in the Metro, I would say he was at least "good", or Edina's defense is "decent", but since no one thinks either of these areas are worth mentioning for Edina, I am confused.

The thing Cashetta is able to do, is to recover from a bad goal, and finish the game strong. This aspect alone will give the Hornets a chance to advance deep next week.

M. Lee is one tender who seems to be on auto pilot with his consistency, but with the hornets averaging over 50 SOG during sections, the law of averages may favor the Hornets in such a match-up. Just a thought..
Edina would not get 50 shots against Roseau. If thats what your getting at.
O-townClown
Posts: 4422
Joined: Wed Oct 10, 2007 12:22 pm
Location: Typical homeboy from the O-Town

agreed

Post by O-townClown »

True, Ogee. And Roseau wouldn't hold them to 8.

Hopefully these two meet. (In the final!)
Be kind. Rewind.
hockeywatcher4
Posts: 164
Joined: Mon Feb 25, 2008 9:12 pm

Re: agreed

Post by hockeywatcher4 »

O-townClown wrote:True, Ogee. And Roseau wouldn't hold them to 8.

Hopefully these two meet. (In the final!)

I think edina would put up about 30 to 35 SOG versus roseau
Svenster
Posts: 15
Joined: Thu Feb 28, 2008 7:37 pm

Post by Svenster »

I'd bet even money that Roseau plays Edina in the championship game.

If Mike Lee is playing at the top of his game, then game over...Roseau wins. No question about it.

If Lee plays mediocre, then it's going to be a toss-up.

It all hinges on Lee (no pressure there!!)...
Cornbread
Posts: 191
Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 9:53 pm

Post by Cornbread »

OGEE OGELTHORPE wrote:
sticksuphigh wrote:
Doc Holliday wrote: Perhaps I watched a different game, but I saw one bad goal & two that were not his fault and would probably have been put past any other goalie in the state.
Considering he had one of the top GAA in the Metro, I would say he was at least "good", or Edina's defense is "decent", but since no one thinks either of these areas are worth mentioning for Edina, I am confused.

The thing Cashetta is able to do, is to recover from a bad goal, and finish the game strong. This aspect alone will give the Hornets a chance to advance deep next week.

M. Lee is one tender who seems to be on auto pilot with his consistency, but with the hornets averaging over 50 SOG during sections, the law of averages may favor the Hornets in such a match-up. Just a thought..
Edina would not get 50 shots against Roseau. If thats what your getting at.
Law of averages still favor Lakevilllllle!!! Get on the bandwagon boyssss!!!!
sticksuphigh
Posts: 116
Joined: Tue Nov 27, 2007 11:18 am

Post by sticksuphigh »

Svenster wrote:I'd bet even money that Roseau plays Edina in the championship game.

If Mike Lee is playing at the top of his game, then game over...Roseau wins. No question about it.

If Lee plays mediocre, then it's going to be a toss-up.

It all hinges on Lee (no pressure there!!)...
Based on the press releases, should it not hinge on the shoulders of Mr. Ness?

P.S. 35 SOG coming from the Budish-Lee-Everson is something else.

I think the majority of Hockey fans want this potential epic match-up [-o<
hockeywatcher4
Posts: 164
Joined: Mon Feb 25, 2008 9:12 pm

Post by hockeywatcher4 »

sticksuphigh wrote:
Svenster wrote:I'd bet even money that Roseau plays Edina in the championship game.

If Mike Lee is playing at the top of his game, then game over...Roseau wins. No question about it.

If Lee plays mediocre, then it's going to be a toss-up.

It all hinges on Lee (no pressure there!!)...
Based on the press releases, should it not hinge on the shoulders of Mr. Ness?

P.S. 35 SOG coming from the Budish-Lee-Everson is something else.

I think the majority of Hockey fans want this potential epic match-up [-o<

I really hope this happens it will be amazing
61ache
Posts: 319
Joined: Wed Mar 07, 2007 10:36 pm
Location: Roseau

Post by 61ache »

sticksuphigh wrote:
Svenster wrote:I'd bet even money that Roseau plays Edina in the championship game.

If Mike Lee is playing at the top of his game, then game over...Roseau wins. No question about it.

If Lee plays mediocre, then it's going to be a toss-up.

It all hinges on Lee (no pressure there!!)...
Based on the press releases, should it not hinge on the shoulders of Mr. Ness?

P.S. 35 SOG coming from the Budish-Lee-Everson is something else.

I think the majority of Hockey fans want this potential epic match-up [-o<
Nope, only Edina has a one dimensional team. Where 3 player on two different lines make up 70% of the offense. If you look at Roseau's stats you'll see the point spread out over 3 lines and d-men. Ness can not put a point and still depend on Nelson, Fabian, Oliver, well the list goes on really
tjkhavgam
Posts: 225
Joined: Tue Aug 28, 2007 1:15 pm

Post by tjkhavgam »

both teams are great ill give it to edina for coming out of a very tough section and ill give it to roseau for an undefeated season so far but if these teams do make it to state it wont be until the championship because they will be the number 1 and 2 seed and because edina uses a very short bench(they play the buddish everson and lee line every other shift) it could possibly be an issue for those 3 kids with there size to be playing 3 games in 3 days at the tourny with the amount of minnutes that they get...another factory is the goalies and roseau is obviously withe the upper hand at this point but these are the best 2 teams in state so either team can win and if we see them play eachother.. it will be one of the best games ever for the state championship
mainefan
Posts: 204
Joined: Wed Oct 31, 2007 6:24 pm

Post by mainefan »

The only time Edina was the best consistently was when a ranger Willard Ikola-Mr. iron range hockey god to you- was coaching Edina. But alas those days are gone and the Hornet's stingers have never been or will be as great again........ :P
Svensta
Posts: 1
Joined: Fri Feb 29, 2008 9:43 am

Post by Svensta »

I'm looking forward to seeing a Roseau Finals against Edina. Both teams are obviously incredibly strong at both ends of the ice. But, Roseau is the team with the superior netminder, without question. And, as most hockey observers will agree, the team with the hot goaltender is probably the team to beat when it comes to tournament play (a good team with a goalie doing magic tricks between the pipes will almost always beat an excellent team with a (merely) good goalie). And, Mike Lee is the real deal. He has a GAA of less than 0.9, a SV% of about 0.95, a perfect record as a varsity goalie, and experience leading the Rams to the Class AA championship in 2007. And, the team he's playing in front of is not merely "good." On top of that, he's from the hockeytown in northern Minnesota with the greatest tradition of high school hockey, not only in the state but, probably, in all of the USA!!!
The Huge Hook
Posts: 221
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2008 10:10 am
Location: South of Hwy. 2

Post by The Huge Hook »

mainefan wrote:The only time Edina was the best consistently was when a ranger Willard Ikola-Mr. iron range hockey god to you- was coaching Edina. But alas those days are gone and the Hornet's stingers have never been or will be as great again........ :P
I see............Ikola had no talented players, he merely coached a bunch of ankle skaters to the state titles because of his fondness for flannell:roll: :roll: :roll:

Just possibly, the great again you refer to is now!
The Huge Hook
Posts: 221
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2008 10:10 am
Location: South of Hwy. 2

Post by The Huge Hook »

Svensta wrote:I'm looking forward to seeing a Roseau Finals against Edina. Both teams are obviously incredibly strong at both ends of the ice. But, Roseau is the team with the superior netminder, without question. And, as most hockey observers will agree, the team with the hot goaltender is probably the team to beat when it comes to tournament play (a good team with a goalie doing magic tricks between the pipes will almost always beat an excellent team with a (merely) good goalie). And, Mike Lee is the real deal. He has a GAA of less than 0.9, a SV% of about 0.95, a perfect record as a varsity goalie, and experience leading the Rams to the Class AA championship in 2007. And, the team he's playing in front of is not merely "good." On top of that, he's from the hockeytown in northern Minnesota with the greatest tradition of high school hockey, not only in the state but, probably, in all of the USA!!!
Impressive 1st post =D> =D> =D>

Welcome to the "bored".
Post Reply