The Roseau paper didn't mention Gardiner last week eithermulefarm wrote:I read in the Mpls. paper Jake Gardiner was the highest ranked Mn. player. No mention of Ness?

Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)
I agree, he's awsome!Lakeviewing wrote:I have watched this kid from Pee Wees, he is good.
Neutron 14 wrote:I agree, he's awsome!Lakeviewing wrote:I have watched this kid at Pee Wee Hermans house,he is good.
I noticed there was not mention of Gardiner in the Hockey News eitherCan't Never Tried wrote:There was no room left!Neutron 14 wrote:For good reason too!ACTUALFORMERPLAYER wrote: The Roseau paper didn't mention Gardiner last week either
I bet Ness would have twice as many points if he was playing a cheesy schedule like Tonka!61ache wrote:I noticed there was not mention of Gardiner in the Hockey News eitherCan't Never Tried wrote:There was no room left!Neutron 14 wrote: For good reason too!
http://thehockeynews.com/listings/111-Y ... e-Ram.html
but they did mention Ness has 49 points in 19 games as a D-man
I Agree, Good player don't get me wrong... but just doesn't have the hands, quickness and hockey sense like Ness...All year I've been hearing about this Gardiner kid. With the game on FSN I was excited to see the kid. There's been so many comparisons to Ness and Gardiner and not to be harsh, but I don't really see it. The kid's hands aren't all that good and he's not that great of a skater. Defensively, it seemed like he hasn't been playing the position long. There were a lot of defensive blunders made, but he does have size. Really not that impressed.
]The_Phantom_Enigma wrote:I Agree, Good player don't get me wrong... but just doesn't have the hands, quickness and hockey sense like Ness...All year I've been hearing about this Gardiner kid. With the game on FSN I was excited to see the kid. There's been so many comparisons to Ness and Gardiner and not to be harsh, but I don't really see it. The kid's hands aren't all that good and he's not that great of a skater. Defensively, it seemed like he hasn't been playing the position long. There were a lot of defensive blunders made, but he does have size. Really not that impressed.
Best you've ever seen? Come on now. I understand if you're a MHS fan and that's cool, but...hockeyfan43 wrote:]The_Phantom_Enigma wrote:I Agree, Good player don't get me wrong... but just doesn't have the hands, quickness and hockey sense like Ness...All year I've been hearing about this Gardiner kid. With the game on FSN I was excited to see the kid. There's been so many comparisons to Ness and Gardiner and not to be harsh, but I don't really see it. The kid's hands aren't all that good and he's not that great of a skater. Defensively, it seemed like he hasn't been playing the position long. There were a lot of defensive blunders made, but he does have size. Really not that impressed.
I disagree he has amazing hands best ive ever seen and he can fly.. I hate minnetonka but this kid is impressive
61ache wrote:Best you've ever seen? Come on now. I understand if you're a MHS fan and that's cool, but...hockeyfan43 wrote:]The_Phantom_Enigma wrote: I Agree, Good player don't get me wrong... but just doesn't have the hands, quickness and hockey sense like Ness...
I disagree he has amazing hands best ive ever seen and he can fly.. I hate minnetonka but this kid is impressive
No, You are a pot stirrer. You are good for starting debate and bumping threads of the states top players and teams. You are entitled to your opinions but as long as you are President of the Gardiner fan club you will not be taken seriously. He has tons of talent and potential but has a long way to go to actually be called a defenseman. His play will cost Tonka any shot at a third game with Edina. Buonomo is good but not good enough to make up for his defensive short comings. He was not the best player on the ice last night or even on his own team. Start your own Gardiner thread and stay there. I doubt any actual Roseau people will go there and say anything negative about him.hockeyfan43 wrote:61ache wrote:Best you've ever seen? Come on now. I understand if you're a MHS fan and that's cool, but...hockeyfan43 wrote:]
I disagree he has amazing hands best ive ever seen and he can fly.. I hate minnetonka but this kid is impressive
and im no skipper fan