The Real Bantam A Rankings!!!

Discussion of Minnesota Youth Hockey

Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)

How is this Ranking?

Great
23
20%
Good
51
44%
Bad
19
16%
Ugly
23
20%
 
Total votes: 116

Pucknutz69
Posts: 861
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2004 4:09 pm

Post by Pucknutz69 »

Chuck Norris Fan wrote:Last Week was a couple of Good tourneys a couple of shabby ones, Duluth, Rochester, Greenway and Crookston. A big WBL tourney this week, lets see who comes out on top. Some good games this last week to make some changes.


1. EP – 2 wins over #5 Brainerd, EP is good!
2. Jefferson/Kennedy – Beats East and Hermantown
3. Duluth East – loss to Jefferson
4. Centennial – Takes down Blaine and is Poised for a District Title, Don't Trip!
5. Wayzata – Walking away with D3
6. Edina – 3-1 Win over Lakeville South
7. Brainerd – a couple of close games with EP but both L's
8. Rochester North – #1 in District 8
9. Tartan – Only one loss in D2
10. Woodbury – #2 in District 8 Playing well
11. Mounds view –

12. Lakeville South – #3 in D8
13. Osseo – playing strong
14. Andover – Lost to Armstrong? = big drop
15. Grand Rapids – Wins Crookston Tourney
16. Hermantown – Good Showing in Duluth
17. Eagan – #4 in District 8, Tied Jefferson in Duluth
18. Elk River – Wins a poor tourney, Barely.
19. Stillwater –Playing better
20. Cottage Grove - Why Not??




Outside looking in: (in this order as per their showing)
Blaine – Absolutly Hammered this last weekend
White Bear Lake – injuries hurt an already down team
Burnsville -
Chaska –
Maple Grove –
St. Cloud –
East Grand -
Apple Valley

Made a small adjustment as to how I think it is.
Rochester beat Edina this weekend. Tartan isn't playing well right now. Woodbury did okay in Duluth. MV hasn't played anyone lately.
woody22
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2006 7:32 pm

Post by woody22 »

For my top ten I would go with...

1. Eden Prairie (Has been playing great)
2. Jefferson
3. Duluth East
4. Rochester North (Beat Edina 3-1)
5. Edina ( Beat Lakeville South and Osseo in Rochester)
6. Centennial
7. Wayzata (I haven't seen them lately so I couldn't judge fairly.)
8. Tartan
9. Brainerd (Heard they are a very solid team)
10. Woodbury
HockeyRocks1
Posts: 142
Joined: Wed Jan 03, 2007 2:46 pm
Location: Not anywhere near Ram Country Unfortunately

Post by HockeyRocks1 »

They are not Rochester North.....Simply Rochester!!!
woody22
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2006 7:32 pm

Post by woody22 »

Oh right my mistake, I forgot that combined.
espnmobile8
Posts: 228
Joined: Sat Dec 30, 2006 11:20 am

Post by espnmobile8 »

Theres only three Kennedy kids on the Jefferson team...even though they were the best players in the Kennedy association=]
Chuck Norris Fan
Posts: 304
Joined: Sun Nov 19, 2006 11:01 pm
Location: North Metro
Contact:

Jefferson Kennedy

Post by Chuck Norris Fan »

Right, I heard that Centennial was only getting three players from Blaine. hmmmm I wonder if they would be better then? Of course they would. Combine any two associations players and see what happens. Don't give me the load of bull about they are one association, last time I checked Kennedy still had a Bantam A team. Jefferson I hope you win this year to make it all worth it. Of course if you don't you could see what Richfield is doing maybe you can take some of their players too.
southernfool
Posts: 63
Joined: Fri Nov 03, 2006 5:40 pm

Post by southernfool »

Jefferdy (as I've seen some call them) is not good enough to win it all. It is a shame when kids abandon their teammates just to try and win a few more games at the youth level.
elliott70
Posts: 15766
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2004 3:47 pm
Location: Bemidji

Post by elliott70 »

If you do not like the transfer - challenge it.
File a grievance with Minnesota Hockey.
Otherwise accept it.
espnmobile8
Posts: 228
Joined: Sat Dec 30, 2006 11:20 am

Post by espnmobile8 »

K, those kids from Kennedy on the Jefferson team transferred because 1) they wanted to go to Jefferson with more of their friends 2) to win at highschool

Im not in total favor of the transfer but I also dont see anything wrong with kids moving to another association to win...its a competition and a business. Deal with it.


And why would you say Jefferson isnt good enough to win it all? Besides EP they've beaten most of those top teams.
selloutcrowd99
Posts: 329
Joined: Sat Dec 02, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by selloutcrowd99 »

I've seen and played against all these teams, and jefferson isn't good enough to beat teams like DE, EP, or maybe even rochester. espnmobile, i guess its time for you to deal with the fact that your team did take players from kennedy and you will be stereotyped for it (and should be too). If it wasn't for those kids, you guys would not be nearly as good as you are now.
DAbears25
Posts: 582
Joined: Wed Dec 20, 2006 3:10 pm

Post by DAbears25 »

selloutcrowd99 wrote:I've seen and played against all these teams, and jefferson isn't good enough to beat teams like DE, EP, or maybe even rochester. espnmobile, i guess its time for you to deal with the fact that your team did take players from kennedy and you will be stereotyped for it (and should be too). If it wasn't for those kids, you guys would not be nearly as good as you are now.

isn't good enough? didnt Jefferson just beat DE in the duluth tournament 3-1 to go to the ship?
espnmobile8
Posts: 228
Joined: Sat Dec 30, 2006 11:20 am

Post by espnmobile8 »

You are really stupid man.
I've seen and played against all these teams, and jefferson isn't good enough to beat teams like DE, EP, or maybe even rochester. espnmobile, i guess its time for you to deal with the fact that your team did take players from kennedy and you will be stereotyped for it (and should be too). If it wasn't for those kids, you guys would not be nearly as good as you are now.
Jefferson has beaten DE and tied EP...so first off that proves you wrong on the first part of your arguement. And I just admitted that Jefferson got kids from Kennedy but they didnt go out and drag em over. Im very glad those kids are on the team, they do make us better, but whats the big deal? Would you want to play for Kennedy? The kids who did transfer made that decision a while back. I knew the Bantam A team would have them my PeeWee A year.
SotaH0ck14
Posts: 263
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 1:48 pm

Post by SotaH0ck14 »

anyone know anything about sartell?
i saw them in lets play hockey rankings i havent heard anything about them
DAbears25
Posts: 582
Joined: Wed Dec 20, 2006 3:10 pm

Post by DAbears25 »

sound pretty decent and were a little unknown i think....looks like they have beaten chaska, minnetonka, and burnsville and tied moorhead in the st. cloud tourney. or maybe they just played the best they have all season and got lucky....im not sure. have a pretty good record also, but alot of wins against not very good teams in D5.
thefan
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Jan 24, 2007 11:16 am

Post by thefan »

Sartell lost to Brainerd in the final seconds of the game... or actually the final SECOND of the game. Brainerd scored as time expired. Hard to tell if they are any good though, Brainerd didn't skate that game and still won. I doubt they deserve to be in the top 20.
selloutcrowd99
Posts: 329
Joined: Sat Dec 02, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by selloutcrowd99 »

Chuck you couldn't have put it any better...
Chuck Norris Fan wrote:Last Week was a couple of Good tourneys a couple of shabby ones, Duluth, Rochester, Greenway and Crookston. A big WBL tourney this week, lets see who comes out on top. Some good games this last week to make some changes.


1. EP – 2 wins over #5 Brainerd, EP is good!
2. Jefferson/Kennedy – Beats East and Hermantown
3. Duluth East – loss to Jefferson
4. Centennial – Takes down Blaine and is Poised for a District Title, Don't Trip!
5. Wayzata – Walking away with D3
6. Edina – 3-1 Win over Lakeville South
7. Brainerd – a couple of close games with EP but both L's
8. Tartan – Only one loss in D2
9. Mounds view –
10. Rochester North – #1 in District 8
11. Woodbury – #2 in District 8 Playing well
12. Lakeville South – #3 in D8
13. Osseo – playing strong
14. Andover – Lost to Armstrong? = big drop
15. Grand Rapids – Wins Crookston Tourney
16. Hermantown – Good Showing in Duluth
17. Eagan – #4 in District 8, Tied Jefferson in Duluth
18. Elk River – Wins a poor tourney, Barely.
19. Stillwater –Playing better
20. Cottage Grove - Why Not??




Outside looking in: (in this order as per their showing)
Blaine – Absolutly Hammered this last weekend
White Bear Lake – injuries hurt an already down team
Burnsville -
Chaska –
Maple Grove –
St. Cloud –
East Grand -
Apple Valley
wild06
Posts: 53
Joined: Thu Nov 30, 2006 6:14 pm

Post by wild06 »

[quote="SotaH0ck14"]anyone know anything about sartell?
i saw them in lets play hockey rankings i havent heard anything about them[/quote]

they are a pretty good team, they dont hav a ton of skill from wat ive seen but they have a ton of heart and that is usually better than skill
dangla8
Posts: 42
Joined: Fri Dec 08, 2006 10:43 pm

Post by dangla8 »

are u sure bout the looking in part with east grand forks
elliott70
Posts: 15766
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2004 3:47 pm
Location: Bemidji

Post by elliott70 »

East Grand Forks is #5 team in District 16.
Roseau is as good (maybe better) than Brainerd.
Bemidji is as good as Grand Rapids.
Crookston is a good team.
Chuck Norris Fan
Posts: 304
Joined: Sun Nov 19, 2006 11:01 pm
Location: North Metro
Contact:

North

Post by Chuck Norris Fan »

I would say I agree with you on the Crookston front. I don't think Bemidji is as good as Rapids and Roseau is getting better, but is not even close to Brainerd.
D16Dad
Posts: 363
Joined: Tue Mar 21, 2006 7:15 pm

Re: North

Post by D16Dad »

Chuck Norris Fan wrote:I would say I agree with you on the Crookston front. I don't think Bemidji is as good as Rapids and Roseau is getting better, but is not even close to Brainerd.
Bemidji did manage to beat Grand Rapids in both meetings. I understand at home it was our Refs and in Rapids they didn't come to play :lol: . Anyway, Brainerd is making a swing through Bemidji, Roseau, and Warroad this weekend. Should be able to get a better measure of a few of the North Region teams...
GR3343
Posts: 1198
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2007 10:39 pm

Re: North

Post by GR3343 »

D16Dad wrote:
Chuck Norris Fan wrote:I would say I agree with you on the Crookston front. I don't think Bemidji is as good as Rapids and Roseau is getting better, but is not even close to Brainerd.
Bemidji did manage to beat Grand Rapids in both meetings. I understand at home it was our Refs and in Rapids they didn't come to play :lol: . Anyway, Brainerd is making a swing through Bemidji, Roseau, and Warroad this weekend. Should be able to get a better measure of a few of the North Region teams...
Don't sound so bitter dad. Bemidji has beaten GR in two 1 goal games, but that's not saying they're a better team. On any given night, anyone can beat anyone. Bemidji has a nice team and if and when they meet up with GR again, I'm sure it will be close. Don't come off so cocky and sarcastic when it comes to GR. They've played one of the tougher schedules in the north and are having a fine season.
Paz DePuk
Posts: 81
Joined: Tue Nov 07, 2006 11:46 pm

Rankings

Post by Paz DePuk »

Might have to take another look at St Cloud. They lost to Brd. in OT playing shorthanded 5 on 4 at the start of OT, 5 on 3 and then back to 5 on 4 when Brd scored.

Against EP, EP set the pace and controlled play in the majority of both games. The difference was the goalie for Brd. Ditto for the Grand Rapids game.
Chuck Norris Fan
Posts: 304
Joined: Sun Nov 19, 2006 11:01 pm
Location: North Metro
Contact:

Post by Chuck Norris Fan »

Last time I checked the goalie was part of the team.
D16Dad
Posts: 363
Joined: Tue Mar 21, 2006 7:15 pm

Re: North

Post by D16Dad »

GR3343 wrote:
D16Dad wrote:
Chuck Norris Fan wrote:I would say I agree with you on the Crookston front. I don't think Bemidji is as good as Rapids and Roseau is getting better, but is not even close to Brainerd.
Bemidji did manage to beat Grand Rapids in both meetings. I understand at home it was our Refs and in Rapids they didn't come to play :lol: . Anyway, Brainerd is making a swing through Bemidji, Roseau, and Warroad this weekend. Should be able to get a better measure of a few of the North Region teams...
Don't sound so bitter dad. Bemidji has beaten GR in two 1 goal games, but that's not saying they're a better team. On any given night, anyone can beat anyone. Bemidji has a nice team and if and when they meet up with GR again, I'm sure it will be close. Don't come off so cocky and sarcastic when it comes to GR. They've played one of the tougher schedules in the north and are having a fine season.
I was trying to be funny :lol: and actually my comments were not directed at GR (responding to Chuck). I was not saying "Bemidji is better than GR", that's kid stuff, but from the games played between Bemidji and GR there is nothing to indicate the opposite either. Bemidji has played a tough schedule as well and has suffered through injuries where the team went 5-5-2 (nothing to be "cocky" about). Bemidji's losses would eliminate them from consideration it seems, but the head to head victories against other teams, in this instance, do not seem to factor in either (ex. Bemidji is 3-0 vs. EGF to date). If this sentence rubbed you the wrong way
D16Dad wrote: I understand at home it was our Refs and in Rapids they didn't come to play :lol: .
I apologize. Put more weight in the second half of the post where I mention that the teams can be measured against another top D12 team (not GR) this weekend.

edit: spelling
Post Reply