The Real 2007 /2008 Bantam A Rankings

Discussion of Minnesota Youth Hockey

Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)

Will EP Repeat?

Fo Sho
49
35%
No way
91
65%
 
Total votes: 140

Mr. Danglz 69
Posts: 23
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 4:43 pm

Post by Mr. Danglz 69 »

norris wats up with chaska being so high? i mean come on they lost all their best players havnt played any of the top 5 teams. Duluth east is the best team in the state they proved it this weekend in the tourny. Also jefferson deserves wayy more credit. if any one saw the tournament this weekend and saw jeffersons games? they out played the majority of the teams they played. they lost in shootouts 2 of the 5 games the last game didnt have a shootout and to top it off the tournament went straight into a shoot out. ther wouldve been a ton of different scores if there was sudden death THEN a shoot out
buckeyehockey17
Posts: 118
Joined: Sat Feb 10, 2007 5:57 pm

Re: 11/ 5

Post by buckeyehockey17 »

Chuck Norris Fan wrote: 11. Jefferson / Kennedy – another year of the Bloomington Combo
Jefferson only has one player from Kennedy this year and they also lost one to Holy Angels
Hockey = Life
Fire and Ice
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:51 am
Location: The Lost City of Centennial

Post by Fire and Ice »

This is Chuck's page so stop making your own 20 get your own like he said! :twisted:
highschoolhockeyfann
Posts: 96
Joined: Mon Nov 12, 2007 6:00 pm

Post by highschoolhockeyfann »

cnf i changed my mind i like your ranking and thinking your doing just fine keep it up and dont listen to me but just a question

do you know when D.E. and E.P. will meet up again im thinking for a minnesota challenge game but dont know the date.
whats the deal with Duluth having 2 tournaments a month apart is there any real big difference besides the teams involved.
thanks
wannagototherink
Posts: 312
Joined: Thu Sep 21, 2006 10:20 am

Post by wannagototherink »

Chuck Norris Fan wrote:Good tourney this Weekend and lots of scores make some changes on the board!

1. EP - Will be here all year
2. East - Put the top to the test. Lost and Tied EP
3. Wayzata - Played Well this weekend
4. Edina - The Next best team
5. Roseau -
6. Champlain / Brooklyn Park – Wow Ripped Blaine....new tops in D10
7. Minnetonka - Good but not great
8. Moorhead - Welcome to the top 10, by beating good teams
9. Chaska –
10. Mahtomedi - Its the End of the road for these guys
11. Woodbury – good goalie
12. Duluth Lakers - Good solid team
13. Centennial - sounds like better play, but got thumped by #3
14. Burnsville –
15. White bear - had a real bad weekend
16. Eagan -
17. Jefferson / Kennedy – Can't score goals
18. Blaine - ouch HOF beating
19. St. Cloud - sounds like they will be a one line team
20. Rochester –



p.s. Hey WANNA get your own page to post your top 20

Fair enough Chuck...
"I've never seen a dumb-bell score a goal!" ~Gretter
wingman
Posts: 79
Joined: Mon Nov 06, 2006 12:37 pm

Chaska being high

Post by wingman »

They have a great goalie and size.
BladeButter44
Posts: 110
Joined: Thu Nov 08, 2007 11:32 am

Post by BladeButter44 »

How is Lakeville South going to look this year with all the loses to the Fire and St. Thomas?
Mr.Penalty
Posts: 98
Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2007 1:23 pm

Re: The Real 2007 /2008 Bantam A Rankings

Post by Mr.Penalty »

Chuck Norris Fan wrote: 1. EP - No Doubt
2. Wayzata - Solid top to bottom
3. East - Should be solid again / no Big goalie this year
4. Mahtomedi - If he stays Marshal is the real deal
5. St. Cloud - If they get them all to play bantams? That is a big IF.
6. Edina - a down year but will be solid
7. White bear - a bunch of size little skill
8. Roseau - Always tough but a slow starter
9. Blaine - Without Bjugstad, they may fall fast
10. Centennial - a down year, will be better than peewees with Larsen in nets

Sorry chuck...don't what your talkin' bout...white bear is very little this year...they have one big kid...alex jarosz...and one tall kid...zach loesch...the rest are ave. size or smaller...but you were right about their little talent...they were a dissapointment in duluth last weekend!!!
wannagototherink
Posts: 312
Joined: Thu Sep 21, 2006 10:20 am

Re: The Real 2007 /2008 Bantam A Rankings

Post by wannagototherink »

Mr.Penalty wrote:
Chuck Norris Fan wrote: 1. EP - No Doubt
2. Wayzata - Solid top to bottom
3. East - Should be solid again / no Big goalie this year
4. Mahtomedi - If he stays Marshal is the real deal
5. St. Cloud - If they get them all to play bantams? That is a big IF.
6. Edina - a down year but will be solid
7. White bear - a bunch of size little skill
8. Roseau - Always tough but a slow starter
9. Blaine - Without Bjugstad, they may fall fast
10. Centennial - a down year, will be better than peewees with Larsen in nets

Sorry chuck...don't what your talkin' bout...white bear is very little this year...they have one big kid...alex jarosz...and one tall kid...zach loesch...the rest are ave. size or smaller...but you were right about their little talent...they were a dissapointment in duluth last weekend!!!

Dude, you want to re-read what you wrote and than remind yourself that they are 14 - 15 year old kids, and than maybe re-read it again!

Some guys are real...
"I've never seen a dumb-bell score a goal!" ~Gretter
Mr.Penalty
Posts: 98
Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2007 1:23 pm

Post by Mr.Penalty »

yea whats your point?
MedleyWR
Posts: 153
Joined: Mon Feb 26, 2007 1:25 pm

Re: The Real 2007 /2008 Bantam A Rankings

Post by MedleyWR »

Mr.Penalty wrote:
Chuck Norris Fan wrote: 1. EP - No Doubt
2. Wayzata - Solid top to bottom
3. East - Should be solid again / no Big goalie this year
4. Mahtomedi - If he stays Marshal is the real deal
5. St. Cloud - If they get them all to play bantams? That is a big IF.
6. Edina - a down year but will be solid
7. White bear - a bunch of size little skill
8. Roseau - Always tough but a slow starter
9. Blaine - Without Bjugstad, they may fall fast
10. Centennial - a down year, will be better than peewees with Larsen in nets

Sorry chuck...don't what your talkin' bout...white bear is very little this year...they have one big kid...alex jarosz...and one tall kid...zach loesch...the rest are ave. size or smaller...but you were right about their little talent...they were a dissapointment in duluth last weekend!!!
Mr. Penalty, you are overlooking four WBL skaters that are 6 feet tall or over. They have a few smaller players as well, but overall, they are one of the larger teams I have seen this year. Also, I think they do have a lot of skill. They played well in pool play in Duluth, losing to Duluth East in a shootout, Wayzata by one and Eden Prairie by two. WBL played poorly in the next round, losing to Centennial and tying Jefferson. But, they are still experimenting with position and line combinations. I believe the coaches will find the right combinations and this team will gel and surprise a lot of people. It is still very early in the season.
DaSTeK
Posts: 59
Joined: Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:08 pm

Post by DaSTeK »

Sorry to be a badass, just questioning.

Doesn't every team still have to "gel", therefore everyone will improve about the same with "chemistry" and end up at the same difference there was before it happened?

lets say

Ep is 10 without chemistry

WBL is 8 without chemistry

WBL improves chemistry to 13 in time.

What does EP do between that time?

I'm sure they improve also,

15-13 EP =]

I'm DEFINITELY agreeing with you, just putting out a logical reason to say a team doesn't necessarily have an upper hand because they haven't "practiced".
Chuck Norris Fan
Posts: 304
Joined: Sun Nov 19, 2006 11:01 pm
Location: North Metro
Contact:

Post by Chuck Norris Fan »

Ok folks, not a lot of games this week but lets see what we can do. There is a good tourneys this upcoming weekend and lots of scores will make some changes to the board!

1. EP - Any questions
2. East -
3. Wayzata - lost to EP 6-3
4. Edina -
5. Moorhead - a top team in the north
6. St. Cloud - beat champlain, lost a tight one to Edina
7. Bemidji - Welcome to the Board with a big win over Roseau
8. Duluth Lakers -
9. Minnetonka -
10. Centennial - Do not count out of D10, they R after all 7 time Defending Champs
11. Eagan - big win over woodbury
12. Champlain / Brooklyn Park – lost to st.cloud 7-4
13. Burnsville –
14. Roseau - lost to Bemidji
15. White bear -
16. Woodbury – lost to Eagan,
17. Jefferson / Kennedy –
18. Chaska –
19. Mahtomedi - how are they now?
20. Rochester –
boblee
Posts: 9146
Joined: Sat Dec 11, 2004 6:57 pm
Location: Fargo, ND
Contact:

post 8587

Post by boblee »

Chuck Norris Fan wrote:Ok folks, not a lot of games this week but lets see what we can do. There is a good tourneys this upcoming weekend and lots of scores will make some changes to the board!

1. EP - Any questions
2. East -
3. Wayzata - lost to EP 6-3
4. Edina -
5. Moorhead - a top team in the north
6. St. Cloud - beat champlain, lost a tight one to Edina
7. Bemidji - Welcome to the Board with a big win over Roseau
8. Duluth Lakers -
9. Minnetonka -
10. Centennial - Do not count out of D10, they R after all 7 time Defending Champs
11. Eagan - big win over woodbury
12. Champlain / Brooklyn Park – lost to st.cloud 7-4
13. Burnsville –
14. Roseau - lost to Bemidji
15. White bear -
16. Woodbury – lost to Eagan,
17. Jefferson / Kennedy –
18. Chaska –
19. Mahtomedi - how are they now?
20. Rochester –
Grand Rapids crushed Alex and Bemidji only beat them by one. I believe Grand Rapids is atleast a top 20 team.
topshelf3
Posts: 53
Joined: Fri Feb 23, 2007 10:44 am

Post by topshelf3 »

Hey Chuck,

Give the Jefferson folks a little credit. We took it to Minnetonka this weekend 5-2. It wasn't a close game as Minnetonka scored their second goal in the last minute of the game.
michaelfloorwax
Posts: 23
Joined: Tue Nov 06, 2007 11:29 pm

Post by michaelfloorwax »

Chuck,

Ok I'll admit you're getting close..
Chaska?? First Shakopee beats them and now Prior Lake beats them 3-1..Get them out of the top 20

Watch Burnsville they're the sleeper of D6.
DaSTeK
Posts: 59
Joined: Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:08 pm

Post by DaSTeK »

Let him make his own decisions, you'll be fooled with how he knows what he's talking about.
michaelfloorwax
Posts: 23
Joined: Tue Nov 06, 2007 11:29 pm

Post by michaelfloorwax »

DaSTeK wrote:Let him make his own decisions, you'll be fooled with how he knows what he's talking about.
So what exactly is your point. You seem to agree with me in your other post?



DaSTeK
Joined: 13 Nov 2007
Posts: 27

Posted: Mon Nov 19, 2007 7:53 pm Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Chaska right now, is not in a dominant scene.

You can't back up a Shakopee AND a Prior Lake loss and call them both flukes.

Sorry, but for those who say Chaska really has a chance in its current state is wrong.

As of now Chaska is definitely not in the top 20.

We did have 11 skaters for the Osseo (5-1) and Prior Lake (3-1 (ENG)) Games.

Maybe bad decisions?

Chaska outshot Prior Lake 30 some to 16.

Simply put, Chaska needs more scorers, or needs it scorers to step up even more.
DaSTeK
Posts: 59
Joined: Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:08 pm

Post by DaSTeK »

I do agree with you, im not contradicting myself

I'm not coming in here saying Take Chaska off Top 20 they dont deserve it. because thats opinions

and Morris has his own opinion.

Don't try to change it.
Goldy Gopher11
Posts: 9
Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 11:25 am

Post by Goldy Gopher11 »

I was not impressed with Rochestor...they may be a little down this year
SMNHockey22
Posts: 60
Joined: Sun Nov 11, 2007 12:09 am

Post by SMNHockey22 »

Well you could at least spell ROCHESTER right. They did lose a few players to the high school program but I mean come on, the top 15 bantam players out of a city of 100,000 that has 4 high schools...they had better be a good team or I feel sorry for the high school hockey fans in Rochester in a few years.
hansenhockey88
Posts: 3
Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 7:20 pm

Post by hansenhockey88 »

St Cloud did get all there players to stay at bantams so they're really good this year. They beat andover 19-0 last weekend and in thief river tournament they took 2nd beating every team by 10 or more so they have a really good squad this year.
SMNHockey22
Posts: 60
Joined: Sun Nov 11, 2007 12:09 am

Post by SMNHockey22 »

You don't have to say they, you can just say we. Also surprises me that a city as big as St. Cloud with 3 high schools and one Bantam A team does well :roll:
bardown012
Posts: 85
Joined: Mon Feb 26, 2007 9:53 am

Post by bardown012 »

So, hansenhockey, what is your best quality win so far this year?
Goldy Gopher11
Posts: 9
Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 11:25 am

Post by Goldy Gopher11 »

Rochestor will be down this year...but Burnsville is pretty good
Post Reply