February 28th Scores and Updates

Older Topics, Not the current discussion

Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)

komada77
Posts: 505
Joined: Thu Jan 03, 2008 11:16 pm

Post by komada77 »

pipes3030 wrote:Who scored for Woodbury?
Eddy (2)
Nelson (2)
Kopp
Pittman
Ogren
Goff? Not sure on this one
Everyone hates private schools (and Edina)!!
mnmouth
Posts: 621
Joined: Mon Mar 05, 2007 4:06 pm

Post by mnmouth »

UNDhockeyfan wrote:
If anyone was at the Minnetonka Benilde play off game last night you are likely as awestruck as I am. Minnetonka's Gardiner fired a shot at the end of the second period that went in hard and came out of the rail just as hard. No one on the ice seemed to realize he scored. I was RIGHT THERE and clearly saw it as did everyone around me who had a great view of it. It wasn't counted nor even talked about.
It would have made the game 3-0 and made Benilde's comeback 1 short.
Wow, what a way to lose. Officiating was not so hot on several occasions but this was the most consequential mistake I have seen in a long time.


Basically the same thing happened in the '78 State Final between Rapids and Edina East. In one of the OT sessions, Rapids player fired the puck that went through Edina goalie's 5-hole, hit the back of the net, came back out through the 5-hole into the crease and was not counted. TV replays clearly showed that it was a goal. Course, Rapids lost, and kept them from 4 titles in 6 years.
UNDhockeyfan
Posts: 9
Joined: Thu Feb 28, 2008 10:17 pm

Re: minnetonka benilde debacle

Post by UNDhockeyfan »

greyhoundsnation27 wrote:
UNDhockeyfan wrote:If anyone was at the Minnetonka Benilde play off game last night you are likely as awestruck as I am. Minnetonka's Gardiner fired a shot at the end of the second period that went in hard and came out of the rail just as hard. No one on the ice seemed to realize he scored. I was RIGHT THERE and clearly saw it as did everyone around me who had a great view of it. It wasn't counted nor even talked about.
It would have made the game 3-0 and made Benilde's comeback 1 short.
Wow, what a way to lose. Officiating was not so hot on several occasions but this was the most consequential mistake I have seen in a long time.

By the way, I am not a Skipers fan or a fan of BSM, just a hockey fan who hates to see injustice. This was as bad as it gets!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
And yes, Gardiner (#19) is the real deal!

:oops:
I was at the game, I was actually sitting about 10 rows behind the Benilde goal. The shot you're talking about definitely did NOT go in the net. It went clean of the post. I really wanted to see Tonka at state but that play didn't lose the game for them, their play in the 3rd and overtime lost the game for them.
No offense, but you are wrong, it went in 1 foot inside the pipe hit the rail and came back out as fast as it went in. The coaches have seen it and know it. Now you do too.
Post Reply