I agree with just about everything you said. There ARE some hurdles involved with getting it started, but I think it's something that's worthwhile and something that WILL eventually happen.spin-o-rama wrote:There have to be some guidelines that are followed. If choice was the criteria then we would have the option(for instance) for teams chosing to have checking at mites, 25 on a roster, or 7X7 play. They are not necessarily bad, but need to be weighed and a decision made if it gives a net benefit. The same with Tier I.
Jancze, you bring up a very good point about available ice. Local community rinks dedicate their prime time ice to the local associations. Not even Wally Shaver can buck this. There are other questions that need to be weighed. Some of mine are:
How many teams? What rule is going to dictate the limit? Are we fine with watered down hockey that is Tier I in name only (see summer hockey)? If you restrict the number, how will you legally be able to defend it when challenged?
How will teams be selected? What is the criteria? One argument for Tier I is that it gives the awesome player rotting on a small association losing team a chance to be on a winning team. How will you guarantee that the Tier I team will be a winning team with great coaching, team management, and development? Many use the Fire of example of positive Tier I experience. How does a startup guarantee that? The Fire still has slip-ups like the coach cert fiasco of last year. Tier I also won’t eliminate power struggles. The Fire had internal strife with a coach who played his kid the whole game. Tier I is not immune to the stereotypical association issues.
Will they be for profit or non profit? MH is dedicated to a non profit model. Tier I generally is not.
Will MH be pressed to provide scholarships for poor kids to play? Or will these teams only serve the affluent?
Those are just my off the cuff questions. There are probably many other concerns. The grass isn't always greener.
My bet is the MM will be the first one to offer a Tier I program in the winter. The groundwork is already being laid with their "Choice" hockey for Mites and Squirts in the winter. And as been said, they also have the ice.