#1 Edina vs Moorhead

Older Topics, Not the current discussion

Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)

Post Reply

#1 Edina vs. Moorhead

Edina
76
64%
Moorhead
43
36%
 
Total votes: 119

grindiangrad-80
Posts: 2611
Joined: Fri Dec 01, 2006 8:00 pm

Post by grindiangrad-80 »

BBB wrote:After seeing the seedings and their draws, I actually wish roseau would have won the section so they could come down to X to get throttled by another bunch of rich, city kids for the third game in row.
But moorhead handled roseau easily and will only lose to Edina by 4 goals, 5-1 is my prediction.
[-X =; :-# :-k

#-o
Dork.
ACTUALFORMERPLAYER
Posts: 632
Joined: Wed Feb 28, 2007 10:54 pm

Post by ACTUALFORMERPLAYER »

knockneed wrote:one thing that we can all count on and that is moorhead outcoaching the hornets. they might not win but their coaching will give them the edge in the tactical game.
Or at least out whine them. Guarentee of the tourney is Dave complains about playing Edina and says something about seeding all 8 teams.
BBB
Posts: 200
Joined: Mon Mar 09, 2009 2:20 pm

Post by BBB »

Well someone should remind dave that he would be a 7 seed and end up playing EP who is neck and neck with edina this year as the 1-2 best teams so far. Section 8AA is weak to say the least this year so that doesnt give him much ammo.
They could remind him of the 10-0 combined score that HM and Edina put on his team at X over x-mas before they won the 7th place game against STA in 4-3 game that people will be talking about for decades. And speaking of 7th place games, his team will most likely be playing Roch Century in the first annual 7th place game at phalen arena at 7:30 am on 3/14/09.
hockeyfan333
Posts: 9
Joined: Mon Mar 02, 2009 12:47 pm

Post by hockeyfan333 »

the regular season means nothing its just like when the 1980 mens hockey team lost to the USSR by some crappy score and then what did they do in the playoffs?????? Regular Season means absolutely nothing.

Make sure to bring the raid to the x....

4-3 spuddies OT
SPUDNUT
Posts: 978
Joined: Sat Dec 23, 2006 11:43 pm
Location: Moorhead

Post by SPUDNUT »

O-townClown wrote:Then figure it out Spudnut and adjust accordingly. I'm sure it changes things completely and will make everyone realize that Moorhead really has accomplished a lot this year.

The list I had from followthepuck showed at least one game against a team from North Dakota. If I've missed another it either wasn't on their site or is a transcription error on my part.

I'll let you worry which.

My point is clear, and obviously missed by delusional Moorhead supporters.

I say:
Edina is far more accomplished and should win easily, but could get beat in a single game if they don't play well or run into a hot goaltender.

You say:
Moorhead is playing better and won't get blown out.

My statement is correct. It acknowledges that there is the potential for any outcome. (Pressed, I predict Edina 5-2.)

Your statement doesn't allow for the obvious possibility that Edina steamrolls Moorhead like they did Holy Angels, Blaine, and Jefferson. All of whom had better seasons so far than Moorhead.
As much as I hate to admit it - I agree with your last assessment of both teams and how the upcoming game will probably go (ouch). All I disputed was that your game numbers didn't add up. The way it sounds, you didn't have the Fargo South score (2-2).
218-to-State
Posts: 57
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2008 3:54 pm

Post by 218-to-State »

grindiangrad-80 wrote:Based on the way Edina handled Jefferson, I would pick them by 4.
Based on the way the tournament can surprise us,
Spuds 4
Edina 3
I know that these games dont really matter anymore, but Moorhead lost in ot to Jefferson and the edina loss had an empty netter so it wasnt like the whole game was dominated by edina. I feel that marks will have a great game. not a shutout, but a great game.

MOORHEAD-4 (EN)
edina-2
218-to-State
Posts: 57
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2008 3:54 pm

Post by 218-to-State »

mnmouth wrote:Every time Moorhead heads to State they disappoint their delusional fans. Might as well call them the White Bear Lake of the North. Perhaps they one day will gain entry into the North Dakota tournament. They could win that.

Edina rolls to meet East in a titanic clash.
Actually. The Spuds have gotten past the first game in their school history. so you cant even compare the bears and spuds in that respect
O-townClown
Posts: 4422
Joined: Wed Oct 10, 2007 12:22 pm
Location: Typical homeboy from the O-Town

that's it

Post by O-townClown »

SPUDNUT wrote:As much as I hate to admit it - I agree with your last assessment of both teams and how the upcoming game will probably go (ouch). All I disputed was that your game numbers didn't add up. The way it sounds, you didn't have the Fargo South score (2-2).
You missed the part in my first post where I cited their PS2 rating. Fargo is in North Dakota and obviously not included. That explains the missing game from their overall record.

I hope Moorhead puts in a good showing. If Edina can't get past them they don't deserve to win state. No excuses. They've waited a long time for this group of kids to be seniors.
Be kind. Rewind.
halla
Posts: 171
Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 9:25 pm

Post by halla »

hockeyfan333 wrote:the regular season means nothing its just like when the 1980 mens hockey team lost to the USSR by some crappy score and then what did they do in the playoffs?????? Regular Season means absolutely nothing.

Make sure to bring the raid to the x....

4-3 spuddies OT
1980, USSR/USA may, in fact, be a fair comparison...
Lakeviewing
Posts: 268
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2008 2:33 am

Edina versus Moorhead

Post by Lakeviewing »

218-to-State wrote:
grindiangrad-80 wrote:Based on the way Edina handled Jefferson, I would pick them by 4.
Based on the way the tournament can surprise us,
Spuds 4
Edina 3
I know that these games dont really matter anymore, but Moorhead lost in ot to Jefferson and the edina loss had an empty netter so it wasnt like the whole game was dominated by edina. I feel that marks will have a great game. not a shutout, but a great game.

MOORHEAD-4 (EN)
edina-2
I would think Edina wins this game in a very tough fought game. If Moorhead plays a body up game with Edina, they might have a chance. Edina's game is to outskate their opponent. No team has really taken the body to Edina and outplayed them physically. Edina in a close game. Then Edina will have to play a very talented Duluth team. I like East beating Edina in a very close game. I think East has the talent to skate with Edina.
SPUDNUT
Posts: 978
Joined: Sat Dec 23, 2006 11:43 pm
Location: Moorhead

Re: Edina versus Moorhead

Post by SPUDNUT »

Lakeviewing wrote:
218-to-State wrote:
grindiangrad-80 wrote:Based on the way Edina handled Jefferson, I would pick them by 4.
Based on the way the tournament can surprise us,
Spuds 4
Edina 3
I know that these games dont really matter anymore, but Moorhead lost in ot to Jefferson and the edina loss had an empty netter so it wasnt like the whole game was dominated by edina. I feel that marks will have a great game. not a shutout, but a great game.

MOORHEAD-4 (EN)
edina-2
I would think Edina wins this game in a very tough fought game. If Moorhead plays a body up game with Edina, they might have a chance. Edina's game is to outskate their opponent. No team has really taken the body to Edina and outplayed them physically. Edina in a close game. Then Edina will have to play a very talented Duluth team. I like East beating Edina in a very close game. I think East has the talent to skate with Edina.
Not sure if the Taters will (or can) take the body. Haven't been as physical as past teams. Have been relying pretty much on their speed this year. Might turn out to be a horse race & I dunno who is faster.
Hockey_High09
Posts: 32
Joined: Thu Jan 15, 2009 9:12 am

Re: Edina versus Moorhead

Post by Hockey_High09 »

SPUDNUT wrote:
Lakeviewing wrote:
218-to-State wrote: I know that these games dont really matter anymore, but Moorhead lost in ot to Jefferson and the edina loss had an empty netter so it wasnt like the whole game was dominated by edina. I feel that marks will have a great game. not a shutout, but a great game.

MOORHEAD-4 (EN)
edina-2
I would think Edina wins this game in a very tough fought game. If Moorhead plays a body up game with Edina, they might have a chance. Edina's game is to outskate their opponent. No team has really taken the body to Edina and outplayed them physically. Edina in a close game. Then Edina will have to play a very talented Duluth team. I like East beating Edina in a very close game. I think East has the talent to skate with Edina.
Not sure if the Taters will (or can) take the body. Haven't been as physical as past teams. Have been relying pretty much on their speed this year. Might turn out to be a horse race & I dunno who is faster.
I'm sure Moorhead is quite fast, but I'm willing to bet that - at their top speed - Edina is faster.
soaker12
Posts: 7
Joined: Sun Mar 08, 2009 10:03 pm

Post by soaker12 »

Without having seen moorhead play, judging by their record I would assume they do not have that *special* player that will score the big goal against an Edina team that has waited for their talented class to become seniors in high school since the squirt level.
Hockey_High09
Posts: 32
Joined: Thu Jan 15, 2009 9:12 am

Post by Hockey_High09 »

soaker12 wrote:Without having seen moorhead play, judging by their record I would assume they do not have that *special* player that will score the big goal against an Edina team that has waited for their talented class to become seniors in high school since the squirt level.
I watched the Edina/Moorhead game at the X during the Schwan Cup and neither team played great. It was actually kind of a boring game, so I'm not going to make a ton of assumptions about it.

I will say that I agree with the comment above, I didn't see a star or "special" player for Moorhead that stood out on the team, but perhaps that has changed.

A lot of Moorhead faithful have posted on this thread, can one of you please let us know where their scoring has come from? Perhaps it's pretty well spread out?? Thanks.
218-to-State
Posts: 57
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2008 3:54 pm

Post by 218-to-State »

http://spudhockey.com/2008-2009Images/G ... s-Gm22.png heres the link to the stats on the Spud Hockey web page
nipeshow18
Posts: 169
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2008 6:35 pm
Location: The Rick

Post by nipeshow18 »

218-to-State wrote:http://spudhockey.com/2008-2009Images/G ... s-Gm22.png heres the link to the stats on the Spud Hockey web page
Hopefully the goals/assists are accurate. I don't know how it was possible to have more goals than shots on goal... (Altenbernd) :roll:
doubleeagle
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Dec 16, 2006 2:56 pm

Post by doubleeagle »

nipeshow18 wrote:
218-to-State wrote:http://spudhockey.com/2008-2009Images/G ... s-Gm22.png heres the link to the stats on the Spud Hockey web page
Hopefully the goals/assists are accurate. I don't know how it was possible to have more goals than shots on goal... (Altenbernd) :roll:
Shots and plus/minus stats were only kept for the 3 Schwan Cup games and 2 or 3 other games,so they're not right.
SPUDNUT
Posts: 978
Joined: Sat Dec 23, 2006 11:43 pm
Location: Moorhead

Re: Edina versus Moorhead

Post by SPUDNUT »

Hockey_High09 wrote:
SPUDNUT wrote:
Lakeviewing wrote: I would think Edina wins this game in a very tough fought game. If Moorhead plays a body up game with Edina, they might have a chance. Edina's game is to outskate their opponent. No team has really taken the body to Edina and outplayed them physically. Edina in a close game. Then Edina will have to play a very talented Duluth team. I like East beating Edina in a very close game. I think East has the talent to skate with Edina.
Not sure if the Taters will (or can) take the body. Haven't been as physical as past teams. Have been relying pretty much on their speed this year. Might turn out to be a horse race & I dunno who is faster.
I'm sure Moorhead is quite fast, but I'm willing to bet that - at their top speed - Edina is faster.

And why is that? Have you seen 'em both? What's your logic? I'd be willing to bet that if the dog hadn't stopped to take a dump, he woulda caught the rabbit.
MNHockey75
Posts: 2144
Joined: Wed Dec 27, 2006 7:12 pm
Location: Bemidji, MN

Post by MNHockey75 »

Edina got a bad draw in my opinion. I think Moorhead is the best of the un-ranked teams, even though their record may not indicate it. When Moorhead brings their A game, they're very tough. I still like the Hornets however by more than a few. HORNETS 5, SPUDS 2

There's going to be pleanty of this at the X.
Image
nipeshow18
Posts: 169
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2008 6:35 pm
Location: The Rick

Post by nipeshow18 »

I just don't see how Moorhead is a 'fast' team like some of you seem to think. Their top end guys definitely have speed I am not denying that at all, but up and down they are by no means a fast team. Just because you have two of the fastest skaters on the ice most of the time in Johnson and Altenbernd doesn't make you a fast team. Edina IS a faster, better team and will prove it on Thursday.
starmvp
Posts: 3224
Joined: Wed Nov 19, 2008 6:12 pm
Location: State of Hockey

Post by starmvp »

nipeshow18 wrote:I just don't see how Moorhead is a 'fast' team like some of you seem to think. Their top end guys definitely have speed I am not denying that at all, but up and down they are by no means a fast team. Just because you have two of the fastest skaters on the ice most of the time in Johnson and Altenbernd doesn't make you a fast team. Edina IS a faster, better team and will prove it on Thursday.
They will prove it and they should have no problem doing it.
UofM
Posts: 22
Joined: Tue Mar 10, 2009 6:46 pm

Post by UofM »

edina should win this game quite handely after a big showing against jefferson in the section finals
mhd_hockey
Posts: 5
Joined: Tue Mar 10, 2009 7:52 pm

Post by mhd_hockey »

MOORHEAD - 3 OT. :!:
EDINA- 2


This is it boys. This is our year. Yess, we all know Edina is a ranked number one, and it will be a tough defete. But i believe deep down that EVERYONE in the stadium is going to be taken back at the game we bring to the X on thursday. All of you are counting moorhead out right away because Edina has the impression on everyone that no matter who they play, they will slaughter. Not going to happen this time. This will be a close, intense game. And our student section will be BRINGINN THE HEAT. Marks is at his best game, and he's not going to let much go by him. All of you Edina fans, i'd be getting a little nervous. These boys have been working their asses off to get here. And they're sure as hell are not letting it go down the drain like we have in the past. This is it. BRING IT ON EDINA!
Dean_O66
Posts: 67
Joined: Thu Feb 12, 2009 11:13 am

Post by Dean_O66 »

mhd_hockey agreed on that people are going to rip you up on here now like i did keep those comments to yourself but im with you buddy!! :D

GO SPUDS!!
MariottiMan
Posts: 20
Joined: Mon Mar 05, 2007 8:37 pm

Post by MariottiMan »

mhd_hockey wrote:MOORHEAD - 3 OT. :!:
EDINA- 2


This is it boys. This is our year. Yess, we all know Edina is a ranked number one, and it will be a tough defete. But i believe deep down that EVERYONE in the stadium is going to be taken back at the game we bring to the X on thursday. All of you are counting moorhead out right away because Edina has the impression on everyone that no matter who they play, they will slaughter. Not going to happen this time. This will be a close, intense game. And our student section will be BRINGINN THE HEAT. Marks is at his best game, and he's not going to let much go by him. All of you Edina fans, i'd be getting a little nervous. These boys have been working their asses off to get here. And they're sure as hell are not letting it go down the drain like we have in the past. This is it. BRING IT ON EDINA!
White Bear fans do this as well (at least the Spud fans have seen a quarter final win)... :lol:

I can see the Spuds winning this contest if they dominate the physical game to knock the Hornets off their game, and their goalie stands on his head. Best of luck to both teams, should be a great game!
- Jay
Post Reply