2010 Ms. Hockey award
Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)
-
- Posts: 22
- Joined: Sat Jun 13, 2009 7:20 am
2010 Ms. Hockey award
Let's Play Hockey 2010 Ms. Hockey featured players
Dec. 17th
Laurel Miller- Totino-Grace HS (University of Wisconsin Madison)
Dec. 23rd
Corinne Buie- Edina HS (Providence College)
Jan. 7th
Kait Mason- Eagan HS (?)
Jan. 14th
Ashley Stenerson- Moorhead HS (?)
Jan. 22nd
Christina LaCombe- Eden Prairie (Syracuse)
Jan. 29th
Gina McDonald Irondale (Harvard)
Dec. 17th
Laurel Miller- Totino-Grace HS (University of Wisconsin Madison)
Dec. 23rd
Corinne Buie- Edina HS (Providence College)
Jan. 7th
Kait Mason- Eagan HS (?)
Jan. 14th
Ashley Stenerson- Moorhead HS (?)
Jan. 22nd
Christina LaCombe- Eden Prairie (Syracuse)
Jan. 29th
Gina McDonald Irondale (Harvard)
Last edited by Minnesota Fan on Sun Jan 31, 2010 3:24 pm, edited 4 times in total.
-
- Posts: 22
- Joined: Sat Jun 13, 2009 7:20 am
Re: 2010 Ms. Hockey award
Jan. 22ndMinnesota Fan wrote:Let's Play Hockey 2010 Ms. Hockey featured players
Dec. 17th
Laurel Miller- Totino-Grace HS (University of Wisconsin Madison)
Dec. 23rd
Corinne Buie- Edina HS (Providence College)
Jan. 7th
Kait Mason- Eagan HS (?)
Jan. 14th
Ashley Stenerson- Moorhead HS (?)
?
-
- Posts: 22
- Joined: Sat Jun 13, 2009 7:20 am
Re: 2010 Ms. Hockey award
Jan. 29th ?Minnesota Fan wrote:Let's Play Hockey 2010 Ms. Hockey featured players
Dec. 17th
Laurel Miller- Totino-Grace HS (University of Wisconsin Madison)
Dec. 23rd
Corinne Buie- Edina HS (Providence College)
Jan. 7th
Kait Mason- Eagan HS (?)
Jan. 14th
Ashley Stenerson- Moorhead HS (?)
Jan. 22nd
Christina LaCombe- Eden Prairie (Syracuse)
-
- Posts: 22
- Joined: Sat Jun 13, 2009 7:20 am
Re: 2010 Ms. Hockey award
Feb. 5th?Minnesota Fan wrote:Let's Play Hockey 2010 Ms. Hockey featured players
Dec. 17th
Laurel Miller- Totino-Grace HS (University of Wisconsin Madison)
Dec. 23rd
Corinne Buie- Edina HS (Providence College)
Jan. 7th
Kait Mason- Eagan HS (?)
Jan. 14th
Ashley Stenerson- Moorhead HS (?)
Jan. 22nd
Christina LaCombe- Eden Prairie (Syracuse)
Jan. 29th
Gina McDonald Irondale (Harvard)
Press Release
Minnesota Ms. Hockey Award top 10 finalists announced
MINNEAPOLIS — Let’s Play Hockey newspaper announced today the top 10 candidates for the 2010 Ms. Hockey Award, which will be presented to the top senior girls’ high school hockey player in Minnesota.
In alphabetical order, here are this year’s top 10 finalists, with college choice:
Finalist School Position College
Rose Alleva Red Wing Defense Princeton
Lauren Barnes Burnsville Forward Mercyhurst
Bethany Brausen Roseville Area Forward Minnesota
Corinne Buie Edina Defense Providence
Amanda Colin Burnsville Forward Quinnipiac
Dana Gallop Grand Rapids/Greenway Forward Minnesota Duluth
Julia Gilbert Proctor/Hermantown/Marshall School Forward TBD
Cara Johnson Hopkins Forward Syracuse
Gina McDonald Irondale Forward Harvard
Amy Olson Roseau Forward St. Cloud State
Nine of the 10 players named as finalists are committed to a Division I school for next season, including three in the WCHA and two in the Ivy League. All finalists have been bound to the textbooks for the past several years as they check in with a cumulative grade-point average of 3.78. Nine of the finalists hail from Class AA schools (Red Wing’s Rose Alleva is the lone player from Class A), and all but two of the finalists are forwards.
The top five finalists for the Ms. Hockey Award will be named in the Feb. 18 edition of Let’s Play Hockey with the winner announced at the Ms. Hockey Awards Banquet on Sunday, Feb. 28, at 11:30 a.m., at the St. Paul RiverCentre. The top 10 finalists for the Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award were also announced today. The five finalists for the Senior Goalie of the Year Award will be named in the Feb. 11 edition of Let’s Play Hockey. Both awards are sponsored by Let’s Play Hockey, the Minnesota Wild and Reebok/CCM.
In addition to on-ice talent, criteria for the Ms. Hockey Award include academics, community/extracurricular activities, citizenship and coachability. The 2009 Ms. Hockey winner was Becky Kortum of Hopkins. Other past winners include Sarah Erickson of Bemidji (2008), Katharine Chute of Blake (2007), Allie Thunstrom of North St. Paul (2006), Gigi Marvin of Warroad (2005), Erica McKenzie of Hastings (2004), Andrea Nichols of Hibbing/Chisholm (2003), Ashley Albrecht of South St. Paul (2002), Renee Curtin of Roseville (2001), Krissy Wendell of Park Center (2000), Ronda Curtin of Roseville (1999), Laura Slominski of Burnsville (1998), Annamarie Holmes of Apple Valley (1997) and Winny Brodt of Roseville (1996).
Other awards that will be presented at the banquet include the Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award, which goes to the top senior goalie in girls’ high school hockey, as well as the Minnesota Girls High School Hockey Coaches Association’s Coaches of the Year, and All-State and All-Academic Award winners for the 2009-10 season.
For more information on the Ms. Hockey banquet, call Let’s Play Hockey at 612-729-0023.
-- LPH --
For Immediate Release Feb. 4, 2010
Contact: Kevin Kurtt (612-729-0023, editor@letsplayhockey.com)
Ten finalists announced for Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award
MINNEAPOLIS — Let’s Play Hockey newspaper announced today the 10 finalists for the 2010 Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award, presented to the top senior girls’ high school hockey goaltender in Minnesota.
The 10 finalists combine for a 2.21 goals-against average, a .914 save and a grade-point average of 3.72. The 10 finalists for the Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award are as follows, in alphabetical order:
Finalist School
Kallie Billadeau Hopkins
Michelle Bonapace-Potvin Rochester John Marshall/Lourdes
Sarah Gustafson Cloquet-Esko-Carlton
Lindsay Kauchick Eastview
Nicole Lund Cloquet-Esko-Carlton
Caitie Morris Edina
Kaitlyn Rolando Tartan
Rachael Snell North St. Paul
Marah Sobczak Stillwater Area
Tamara Twite East Grand Forks
The top five finalists for the Senior Goalie of the Year Award will be named in the Feb. 11 edition of Let’s Play Hockey with the winner announced at the Ms. Hockey Awards Banquet on Sunday, Feb. 28, at 11:30 a.m., at the St. Paul RiverCentre. The top 10 finalists for the Ms. Hockey Award were also announced today. The five finalists for Ms. Hockey will be named in the Feb. 18 edition of Let’s Play Hockey. Both awards are sponsored by Let’s Play Hockey, the Minnesota Wild and Reebok/CCM.
In addition to on-ice talent, criteria for the Senior Goalie of the Year Award include academics, community/extracurricular activities, citizenship and coachability.
The 2009 Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award winner was Laura Bellamy of Duluth. Other past winners include: Alyssa Grogan of Eagan (2008), Ashley Nixon of Blaine (2007), Allana McCready of Centennial (2006), Johanna Ellison of Cloquet/Esko/Carlton (2005), Emily Brookshaw of Hill-Murray (2004), Robin Doepke of Chaska (2003), Amber Hasbargen of Warroad (2002), Jody Horak of Blaine (2001), Shari Vogt of River Lakes (2000) and Katie Beauduy of Blaine (1999).
Other awards that will be presented at the banquet include the Ms. Hockey Award, which goes to the top senior in girls’ high school hockey, as well as the Minnesota Girls High School Hockey Coaches Association’s Coaches of the Year, and All-State and All-Academic Award winners for the 2009-10 season.
For more information on the Ms. Hockey banquet, call Let’s Play Hockey at 612-729-0023.
MINNEAPOLIS — Let’s Play Hockey newspaper announced today the top 10 candidates for the 2010 Ms. Hockey Award, which will be presented to the top senior girls’ high school hockey player in Minnesota.
In alphabetical order, here are this year’s top 10 finalists, with college choice:
Finalist School Position College
Rose Alleva Red Wing Defense Princeton
Lauren Barnes Burnsville Forward Mercyhurst
Bethany Brausen Roseville Area Forward Minnesota
Corinne Buie Edina Defense Providence
Amanda Colin Burnsville Forward Quinnipiac
Dana Gallop Grand Rapids/Greenway Forward Minnesota Duluth
Julia Gilbert Proctor/Hermantown/Marshall School Forward TBD
Cara Johnson Hopkins Forward Syracuse
Gina McDonald Irondale Forward Harvard
Amy Olson Roseau Forward St. Cloud State
Nine of the 10 players named as finalists are committed to a Division I school for next season, including three in the WCHA and two in the Ivy League. All finalists have been bound to the textbooks for the past several years as they check in with a cumulative grade-point average of 3.78. Nine of the finalists hail from Class AA schools (Red Wing’s Rose Alleva is the lone player from Class A), and all but two of the finalists are forwards.
The top five finalists for the Ms. Hockey Award will be named in the Feb. 18 edition of Let’s Play Hockey with the winner announced at the Ms. Hockey Awards Banquet on Sunday, Feb. 28, at 11:30 a.m., at the St. Paul RiverCentre. The top 10 finalists for the Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award were also announced today. The five finalists for the Senior Goalie of the Year Award will be named in the Feb. 11 edition of Let’s Play Hockey. Both awards are sponsored by Let’s Play Hockey, the Minnesota Wild and Reebok/CCM.
In addition to on-ice talent, criteria for the Ms. Hockey Award include academics, community/extracurricular activities, citizenship and coachability. The 2009 Ms. Hockey winner was Becky Kortum of Hopkins. Other past winners include Sarah Erickson of Bemidji (2008), Katharine Chute of Blake (2007), Allie Thunstrom of North St. Paul (2006), Gigi Marvin of Warroad (2005), Erica McKenzie of Hastings (2004), Andrea Nichols of Hibbing/Chisholm (2003), Ashley Albrecht of South St. Paul (2002), Renee Curtin of Roseville (2001), Krissy Wendell of Park Center (2000), Ronda Curtin of Roseville (1999), Laura Slominski of Burnsville (1998), Annamarie Holmes of Apple Valley (1997) and Winny Brodt of Roseville (1996).
Other awards that will be presented at the banquet include the Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award, which goes to the top senior goalie in girls’ high school hockey, as well as the Minnesota Girls High School Hockey Coaches Association’s Coaches of the Year, and All-State and All-Academic Award winners for the 2009-10 season.
For more information on the Ms. Hockey banquet, call Let’s Play Hockey at 612-729-0023.
-- LPH --
For Immediate Release Feb. 4, 2010
Contact: Kevin Kurtt (612-729-0023, editor@letsplayhockey.com)
Ten finalists announced for Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award
MINNEAPOLIS — Let’s Play Hockey newspaper announced today the 10 finalists for the 2010 Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award, presented to the top senior girls’ high school hockey goaltender in Minnesota.
The 10 finalists combine for a 2.21 goals-against average, a .914 save and a grade-point average of 3.72. The 10 finalists for the Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award are as follows, in alphabetical order:
Finalist School
Kallie Billadeau Hopkins
Michelle Bonapace-Potvin Rochester John Marshall/Lourdes
Sarah Gustafson Cloquet-Esko-Carlton
Lindsay Kauchick Eastview
Nicole Lund Cloquet-Esko-Carlton
Caitie Morris Edina
Kaitlyn Rolando Tartan
Rachael Snell North St. Paul
Marah Sobczak Stillwater Area
Tamara Twite East Grand Forks
The top five finalists for the Senior Goalie of the Year Award will be named in the Feb. 11 edition of Let’s Play Hockey with the winner announced at the Ms. Hockey Awards Banquet on Sunday, Feb. 28, at 11:30 a.m., at the St. Paul RiverCentre. The top 10 finalists for the Ms. Hockey Award were also announced today. The five finalists for Ms. Hockey will be named in the Feb. 18 edition of Let’s Play Hockey. Both awards are sponsored by Let’s Play Hockey, the Minnesota Wild and Reebok/CCM.
In addition to on-ice talent, criteria for the Senior Goalie of the Year Award include academics, community/extracurricular activities, citizenship and coachability.
The 2009 Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award winner was Laura Bellamy of Duluth. Other past winners include: Alyssa Grogan of Eagan (2008), Ashley Nixon of Blaine (2007), Allana McCready of Centennial (2006), Johanna Ellison of Cloquet/Esko/Carlton (2005), Emily Brookshaw of Hill-Murray (2004), Robin Doepke of Chaska (2003), Amber Hasbargen of Warroad (2002), Jody Horak of Blaine (2001), Shari Vogt of River Lakes (2000) and Katie Beauduy of Blaine (1999).
Other awards that will be presented at the banquet include the Ms. Hockey Award, which goes to the top senior in girls’ high school hockey, as well as the Minnesota Girls High School Hockey Coaches Association’s Coaches of the Year, and All-State and All-Academic Award winners for the 2009-10 season.
For more information on the Ms. Hockey banquet, call Let’s Play Hockey at 612-729-0023.
-
- Posts: 22
- Joined: Sat Jun 13, 2009 7:20 am
Re: Press Release
allhoc11-allhoc11 wrote:Minnesota Ms. Hockey Award top 10 finalists announced
MINNEAPOLIS — Let’s Play Hockey newspaper announced today the top 10 candidates for the 2010 Ms. Hockey Award, which will be presented to the top senior girls’ high school hockey player in Minnesota.
In alphabetical order, here are this year’s top 10 finalists, with college choice:
Finalist School Position College
Rose Alleva Red Wing Defense Princeton
Lauren Barnes Burnsville Forward Mercyhurst
Bethany Brausen Roseville Area Forward Minnesota
Corinne Buie Edina Defense Providence
Amanda Colin Burnsville Forward Quinnipiac
Dana Gallop Grand Rapids/Greenway Forward Minnesota Duluth
Julia Gilbert Proctor/Hermantown/Marshall School Forward TBD
Cara Johnson Hopkins Forward Syracuse
Gina McDonald Irondale Forward Harvard
Amy Olson Roseau Forward St. Cloud State
Nine of the 10 players named as finalists are committed to a Division I school for next season, including three in the WCHA and two in the Ivy League. All finalists have been bound to the textbooks for the past several years as they check in with a cumulative grade-point average of 3.78. Nine of the finalists hail from Class AA schools (Red Wing’s Rose Alleva is the lone player from Class A), and all but two of the finalists are forwards.
The top five finalists for the Ms. Hockey Award will be named in the Feb. 18 edition of Let’s Play Hockey with the winner announced at the Ms. Hockey Awards Banquet on Sunday, Feb. 28, at 11:30 a.m., at the St. Paul RiverCentre. The top 10 finalists for the Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award were also announced today. The five finalists for the Senior Goalie of the Year Award will be named in the Feb. 11 edition of Let’s Play Hockey. Both awards are sponsored by Let’s Play Hockey, the Minnesota Wild and Reebok/CCM.
In addition to on-ice talent, criteria for the Ms. Hockey Award include academics, community/extracurricular activities, citizenship and coachability. The 2009 Ms. Hockey winner was Becky Kortum of Hopkins. Other past winners include Sarah Erickson of Bemidji (2008), Katharine Chute of Blake (2007), Allie Thunstrom of North St. Paul (2006), Gigi Marvin of Warroad (2005), Erica McKenzie of Hastings (2004), Andrea Nichols of Hibbing/Chisholm (2003), Ashley Albrecht of South St. Paul (2002), Renee Curtin of Roseville (2001), Krissy Wendell of Park Center (2000), Ronda Curtin of Roseville (1999), Laura Slominski of Burnsville (1998), Annamarie Holmes of Apple Valley (1997) and Winny Brodt of Roseville (1996).
Other awards that will be presented at the banquet include the Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award, which goes to the top senior goalie in girls’ high school hockey, as well as the Minnesota Girls High School Hockey Coaches Association’s Coaches of the Year, and All-State and All-Academic Award winners for the 2009-10 season.
For more information on the Ms. Hockey banquet, call Let’s Play Hockey at 612-729-0023.
-- LPH --
For Immediate Release Feb. 4, 2010
Contact: Kevin Kurtt (612-729-0023, editor@letsplayhockey.com)
Ten finalists announced for Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award
MINNEAPOLIS — Let’s Play Hockey newspaper announced today the 10 finalists for the 2010 Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award, presented to the top senior girls’ high school hockey goaltender in Minnesota.
The 10 finalists combine for a 2.21 goals-against average, a .914 save and a grade-point average of 3.72. The 10 finalists for the Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award are as follows, in alphabetical order:
Finalist School
Kallie Billadeau Hopkins
Michelle Bonapace-Potvin Rochester John Marshall/Lourdes
Sarah Gustafson Cloquet-Esko-Carlton
Lindsay Kauchick Eastview
Nicole Lund Cloquet-Esko-Carlton
Caitie Morris Edina
Kaitlyn Rolando Tartan
Rachael Snell North St. Paul
Marah Sobczak Stillwater Area
Tamara Twite East Grand Forks
The top five finalists for the Senior Goalie of the Year Award will be named in the Feb. 11 edition of Let’s Play Hockey with the winner announced at the Ms. Hockey Awards Banquet on Sunday, Feb. 28, at 11:30 a.m., at the St. Paul RiverCentre. The top 10 finalists for the Ms. Hockey Award were also announced today. The five finalists for Ms. Hockey will be named in the Feb. 18 edition of Let’s Play Hockey. Both awards are sponsored by Let’s Play Hockey, the Minnesota Wild and Reebok/CCM.
In addition to on-ice talent, criteria for the Senior Goalie of the Year Award include academics, community/extracurricular activities, citizenship and coachability.
The 2009 Let’s Play Hockey Senior Goalie of the Year Award winner was Laura Bellamy of Duluth. Other past winners include: Alyssa Grogan of Eagan (2008), Ashley Nixon of Blaine (2007), Allana McCready of Centennial (2006), Johanna Ellison of Cloquet/Esko/Carlton (2005), Emily Brookshaw of Hill-Murray (2004), Robin Doepke of Chaska (2003), Amber Hasbargen of Warroad (2002), Jody Horak of Blaine (2001), Shari Vogt of River Lakes (2000) and Katie Beauduy of Blaine (1999).
Other awards that will be presented at the banquet include the Ms. Hockey Award, which goes to the top senior in girls’ high school hockey, as well as the Minnesota Girls High School Hockey Coaches Association’s Coaches of the Year, and All-State and All-Academic Award winners for the 2009-10 season.
For more information on the Ms. Hockey banquet, call Let’s Play Hockey at 612-729-0023.
You beat me to it.
Congratulations girls!
My money is on Buie.
Re: Press Release
Minnesota Fan wrote: allhoc11-
You beat me to it.
Congratulations girls!
My money is on Buie.
My money is on McDonald. Classy girl.
Re: Press Release
You're assuming the voters didn't see this game?Sparlimb wrote:
My money is on McDonald. Classy girl.

http://www.minnesotasportsonline.com/ga ... meid=35511
All of these girls are great great players and deserving. Let's just say I have to favor the girl in our conference the strongest conference/section. No weakness plays both ways and true leader. My daughter's a D so I wouldn't mind any of the D winning. Of course I know there's only 1.
Please know all are very deserving and really wouldn't mind any of them winning. All are amazing.
Best of luck to all.
Please know all are very deserving and really wouldn't mind any of them winning. All are amazing.
Best of luck to all.
Agreed, anyone else surprised that there is only 1 D in the top 10? There are some very good D that didn't make it, and I would say if I was picking I would have maybe 4 or 5 in my top 10......is it time for a defensive player of the year? Just seems it's hard to get good Defensive players recognized, but I guess if you play that position you are used to it.Melvin44 wrote:All of these girls are great great players and deserving. Let's just say I have to favor the girl in our conference the strongest conference/section. No weakness plays both ways and true leader. My daughter's a D so I wouldn't mind any of the D winning. Of course I know there's only 1.
Please know all are very deserving and really wouldn't mind any of them winning. All are amazing.
Best of luck to all.
Defense is the toughest position to get recognized. When you pitch a shutout it's the goalie. When you score it's usually a forward.
If they score they say the d sucked and don't look at the 3 forwards also on the ice. Rarely are D given a 2nd assists. If you skate the puck up your an offensive hog. People sometimes don't realize that maybe the d forced most of the shots from the outside or blocked 4 key shots during a game. They don't think of how the d got the puck made a quick outlet pass which started the game winning goal.
I know life sucks sometimes. Suck it up!
I know some of you probably are saying he thinks his daughter should have been nominated. Honestly I think she's an awesome player and girl. But she's not the type of player who wins this type of award and would rather have a friend or teamate win.
She was very happy and excited for all her friends who were nominated. I asked her who she thought should win and said all of them.
Again good luck to ALL of these special players.
I will say I thought a lot of D having great years could have been nominated. Maggie, Elle, Christina, Laurel, Katie, Dani, Allie, Chelsea, Stephanie, Megan.
If they score they say the d sucked and don't look at the 3 forwards also on the ice. Rarely are D given a 2nd assists. If you skate the puck up your an offensive hog. People sometimes don't realize that maybe the d forced most of the shots from the outside or blocked 4 key shots during a game. They don't think of how the d got the puck made a quick outlet pass which started the game winning goal.
I know life sucks sometimes. Suck it up!
I know some of you probably are saying he thinks his daughter should have been nominated. Honestly I think she's an awesome player and girl. But she's not the type of player who wins this type of award and would rather have a friend or teamate win.
She was very happy and excited for all her friends who were nominated. I asked her who she thought should win and said all of them.
Again good luck to ALL of these special players.
I will say I thought a lot of D having great years could have been nominated. Maggie, Elle, Christina, Laurel, Katie, Dani, Allie, Chelsea, Stephanie, Megan.
I have always thought there should be a separate award given to the top forward, the top defensive player, and the top goalie. While they all play as a team to win, they have very different roles. It is hard to compare a strong defensive-minded D to a forward who makes plays and scores goals. (I have always thought the best defensive players are those that stop the other team from scoring.) There is a separate award for the top goalie ... I think it is time to recognize the top defensive players for what they contribute to a team.allhoc11 wrote:Agreed, anyone else surprised that there is only 1 D in the top 10? There are some very good D that didn't make it, and I would say if I was picking I would have maybe 4 or 5 in my top 10......is it time for a defensive player of the year? Just seems it's hard to get good Defensive players recognized, but I guess if you play that position you are used to it.Melvin44 wrote:All of these girls are great great players and deserving. Let's just say I have to favor the girl in our conference the strongest conference/section. No weakness plays both ways and true leader. My daughter's a D so I wouldn't mind any of the D winning. Of course I know there's only 1.
Please know all are very deserving and really wouldn't mind any of them winning. All are amazing.
Best of luck to all.
As Melvin pointed out, there are some very deserving senior D who did not get recognized for this award, including his daughter.
The only problem with having an award for top defensive player is that usually it goes to the defenseman with the best offensive performance. I've never seen an award for the best defensive stay-at-home defenseman. Like the Defensive Player of the Week award in the WCHA either goes to a goalie or else a defenseman who get 4 points in a weekend.
My favorite D in the last 5 years was Kelly Wild. She'd get walked around more than her share, but she was the most exciting offensive player in the section her senior year. Does she win a defenseman of the year award?
My favorite D in the last 5 years was Kelly Wild. She'd get walked around more than her share, but she was the most exciting offensive player in the section her senior year. Does she win a defenseman of the year award?
I think there should be a separate award for the best D because its too hard to compete with Forwards since they typically have gaudy stats compared to the D. However, I think you have to look at the offensive stats for D and compare them against other D (instead of Fs). Not that it should be the only measure of a D but the most dangerous D are ones that can get points too (Gs and As). I think the top D wouldn't necessarily lead the MSHSL in points for D but they would have to get some points.Bensonmum wrote:The only problem with having an award for top defensive player is that usually it goes to the defenseman with the best offensive performance. I've never seen an award for the best defensive stay-at-home defenseman. Like the Defensive Player of the Week award in the WCHA either goes to a goalie or else a defenseman who get 4 points in a weekend.
My favorite D in the last 5 years was Kelly Wild. She'd get walked around more than her share, but she was the most exciting offensive player in the section her senior year. Does she win a defenseman of the year award?
I agree with Benny. The best defender award would go to the D who had 30 goals and 7 assists. No offense to anyone but I like a d to have more assists than goals. You would think they would be smart enought and figure there is more than just pts. Same goes for all conf, state.
Please let me say again that ALL the girls who are mentioned for this award are ALL deserving and special players. I honestly would be happy for any winner.
All teams play very strong teams and conference should never matter. I'm just a homer for our conference.
Good luck to ALL the girls. Honest!
Please let me say again that ALL the girls who are mentioned for this award are ALL deserving and special players. I honestly would be happy for any winner.
All teams play very strong teams and conference should never matter. I'm just a homer for our conference.
Good luck to ALL the girls. Honest!
I agree that a defenseman should be able to play both ways and should contribute offensively. Judging the defense objectively is a very difficult thing to do. You may also have a player that plays both forward and defense, which also muddies the water.OntheEdge wrote:I think there should be a separate award for the best D because its too hard to compete with Forwards since they typically have gaudy stats compared to the D. However, I think you have to look at the offensive stats for D and compare them against other D (instead of Fs). Not that it should be the only measure of a D but the most dangerous D are ones that can get points too (Gs and As). I think the top D wouldn't necessarily lead the MSHSL in points for D but they would have to get some points.Bensonmum wrote:The only problem with having an award for top defensive player is that usually it goes to the defenseman with the best offensive performance. I've never seen an award for the best defensive stay-at-home defenseman. Like the Defensive Player of the Week award in the WCHA either goes to a goalie or else a defenseman who get 4 points in a weekend.
My favorite D in the last 5 years was Kelly Wild. She'd get walked around more than her share, but she was the most exciting offensive player in the section her senior year. Does she win a defenseman of the year award?
Maybe using plus/minus stats as a percentage of total goals for/against would be a good indicator. I hope I said that right. My intention is to say that plus/minus alone doesn't do much because there might be a defenseman who plays on a team that dominates its weaker opponents in conference play and really racks up the points -- naturally, those plus/minus #s would be higher than a defenseman who plays in a tougher conference where not as many goals are scored. Maybe I'm just getting deeper in my own poo here ...
At any rate, it would be nice to see a separate defensive award given out. I'm sure there are people way smarter than I am that could come up with some objective ways to evaluate defensemen against defensemen.
I first of all want to congratulate the top ten Ms. Hockey and the top ten Ms. Goalie candidates. What an honor and all very deserving of this wonderful award.
Next I want to pay tribute to the defense. Out of the 22 high school girls that have committed to play for D1 schools there are 10 forwards, 10 defense and 2 goalies. I believe this is the highest percentage of defenders committing to play D1 hockey ever. This years defenders are as different as they come. I have seen every one of these girls play and boy can they play the game. I have my favorites but they all bring something different to the game. I feel that they have been shorted when it comes to these awards and it is high time we have a Ms. Defense. I made up a list of the ten defenders that are going on to play D1 college hockey with their stats. When it comes to defenders you really need to go to a few games and watch them play. I hope you have enjoyed this class of defenders as much as I have. I don’t think we will see another class of this caliber or size in a long time. They are pretty special young ladies.
1. Rose Alleva- Red Wing- Princeton 31-25=56
2. Laurel Miller- Totino-Grace- Wisconsin 15-21=36
3. Christina LaCombe- Eden Prairie-Syracuse 18-16=34
3. Maggie Pendleton- Hill Murray- Providence 10-24=34
5. Allie Duellman- Roseville- Bemidji 11-20=31
6. Megan Dalbec- Champlin Park- Vermont 13-7=20
6. Maddie Marcotte- White Bear Lake- Ohio 7-13=20
8. Ellie Gleason- Edina- Dartmouth 4-11=15
9. Amanda Monkman- Roseau- St. Cloud 4-10=14
10. Danielle Scholzien- Blaine- Mankato 1-10=11
Next I want to pay tribute to the defense. Out of the 22 high school girls that have committed to play for D1 schools there are 10 forwards, 10 defense and 2 goalies. I believe this is the highest percentage of defenders committing to play D1 hockey ever. This years defenders are as different as they come. I have seen every one of these girls play and boy can they play the game. I have my favorites but they all bring something different to the game. I feel that they have been shorted when it comes to these awards and it is high time we have a Ms. Defense. I made up a list of the ten defenders that are going on to play D1 college hockey with their stats. When it comes to defenders you really need to go to a few games and watch them play. I hope you have enjoyed this class of defenders as much as I have. I don’t think we will see another class of this caliber or size in a long time. They are pretty special young ladies.
1. Rose Alleva- Red Wing- Princeton 31-25=56
2. Laurel Miller- Totino-Grace- Wisconsin 15-21=36
3. Christina LaCombe- Eden Prairie-Syracuse 18-16=34
3. Maggie Pendleton- Hill Murray- Providence 10-24=34
5. Allie Duellman- Roseville- Bemidji 11-20=31
6. Megan Dalbec- Champlin Park- Vermont 13-7=20
6. Maddie Marcotte- White Bear Lake- Ohio 7-13=20
8. Ellie Gleason- Edina- Dartmouth 4-11=15
9. Amanda Monkman- Roseau- St. Cloud 4-10=14
10. Danielle Scholzien- Blaine- Mankato 1-10=11
-
- Posts: 30
- Joined: Sat Jul 05, 2008 12:46 pm
I like your comments about defense. But it looks a little like your order is based on pts. Pts are a little skewed. My point is look at the top 3 players all are sometimes the only option on there team and therefore they have the choice to do whatever they want. Which is fine but not exactly defense. Another point is who are they scoring against? top teams? little sisters of the poor? which again is fine. Also when were they signed? which I think Gleason Monkman and Pendleton were the earliest. obviously if they signed early the reason was probabley college coaches were more interested. I've seen many of these girls play and would agree that when the signed is close to the order of their talent. an opinion. I will say most are very close in overall talent. You seem like a proud parent of one of the girls who has a lot of pts. the point i'm making is there are many things to consider other than pts. but nice of you to mention the defense.quickfeet wrote:I first of all want to congratulate the top ten Ms. Hockey and the top ten Ms. Goalie candidates. What an honor and all very deserving of this wonderful award.
Next I want to pay tribute to the defense. Out of the 22 high school girls that have committed to play for D1 schools there are 10 forwards, 10 defense and 2 goalies. I believe this is the highest percentage of defenders committing to play D1 hockey ever. This years defenders are as different as they come. I have seen every one of these girls play and boy can they play the game. I have my favorites but they all bring something different to the game. I feel that they have been shorted when it comes to these awards and it is high time we have a Ms. Defense. I made up a list of the ten defenders that are going on to play D1 college hockey with their stats. When it comes to defenders you really need to go to a few games and watch them play. I hope you have enjoyed this class of defenders as much as I have. I don’t think we will see another class of this caliber or size in a long time. They are pretty special young ladies.
1. Rose Alleva- Red Wing- Princeton 31-25=56
2. Laurel Miller- Totino-Grace- Wisconsin 15-21=36
3. Christina LaCombe- Eden Prairie-Syracuse 18-16=34
3. Maggie Pendleton- Hill Murray- Providence 10-24=34
5. Allie Duellman- Roseville- Bemidji 11-20=31
6. Megan Dalbec- Champlin Park- Vermont 13-7=20
6. Maddie Marcotte- White Bear Lake- Ohio 7-13=20
8. Ellie Gleason- Edina- Dartmouth 4-11=15
9. Amanda Monkman- Roseau- St. Cloud 4-10=14
10. Danielle Scholzien- Blaine- Mankato 1-10=11
Every opinion is different unless you actually see these players it's hard to judge this award. My opinion would be to put a unbiased panel together and actually go out and watch these players and then make a decision.
If you can't actually watch a player you can't judge them. It's as simple as that.
I'm pretty sure they look at more than just stats. At least I hope so.
If you can't actually watch a player you can't judge them. It's as simple as that.
I'm pretty sure they look at more than just stats. At least I hope so.
I agree with you Melvin. I did not intend to offend anybody, I only wanted to give a little credit to the defenders. I picked the ten that had committed to a D1 college.Melvin44 wrote:Every opinion is different unless you actually see these players it's hard to judge this award. My opinion would be to put a unbiased panel together and actually go out and watch these players and then make a decision.
If you can't actually watch a player you can't judge them. It's as simple as that.
I'm pretty sure they look at more than just stats. At least I hope so.
Last edited by quickfeet on Mon Feb 08, 2010 6:14 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I know. I always love your posts. You seem to know the game very well. Somtimes parents try to defend based on location. North, South, East, or West all passionate.quickfeet wrote:I agree with you Melvin. I did not attend to offend anybody, I only wanted to give a little credit to the defenders. I picked the ten that had committed to a D1 college.Melvin44 wrote:Every opinion is different unless you actually see these players it's hard to judge this award. My opinion would be to put a unbiased panel together and actually go out and watch these players and then make a decision.
If you can't actually watch a player you can't judge them. It's as simple as that.
I'm pretty sure they look at more than just stats. At least I hope so.
I do like some D not mentioned and feel they will be playing D1 hockey if they want. I know it's hard to say everyone.
There will be more signings.