STMA
Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)
-
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2012 9:29 am
- Location: Met Center Press Box
STMA
The NWSC voted Friday to only accept Rogers into the league for 2019-20. Keeps it at a 14 team league as Irondale drops out of the league.
Would think the Lake is the only league that would take them? Buffalo also applied and was turned down.
Would think the Lake is the only league that would take them? Buffalo also applied and was turned down.
Re: STMA
Interesting turn of events. Rogers isn’t exactly a powerhouse in most sports, but I guess it makes sense to pair them in the same conference with district mate Elk River. Presumably Irondale will be heading to the Suburban East?alcloseshaver wrote:The NWSC voted Friday to only accept Rogers into the league for 2019-20. Keeps it at a 14 team league as Irondale drops out of the league.
Would think the Lake is the only league that would take them? Buffalo also applied and was turned down.
The Lake seems like an odd fit for STMA in terms of geography and demographics, but they have also clearly outgrown the Miss 8. Those two schools moving may set off a chain reaction of realignment among the remaining teams in the Miss 8.
-
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2012 9:29 am
- Location: Met Center Press Box
-
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2012 9:29 am
- Location: Met Center Press Box
-
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2012 9:29 am
- Location: Met Center Press Box
The growth of the STMA school district is hard to keep up with. They probably should have had a little more foresight and been looking to move a few years ago. The NWSC would a perfect fit and would have kept some good rivalries and with an enrollment of 1800 they are skipping a step in the progression and jumping to the only league that will take them. The only comp I can think of is when Eden Praire exploded.
The STMA administration has been (overly?) cautious regarding their growth projections largely because being aggressive with the projections burned them in the past. During the housing boom and bust of the previous decade, STMA went on a school building spree to accommodate major projected growth, but then ended up with several half-empty schools after the foreclosure crisis hit the area hard. That said, I agree that the district lacked foresight in trying to find a new home for their athletic programs before things hit crisis mode recently.alcloseshaver wrote:The growth of the STMA school district is hard to keep up with. They probably should have had a little more foresight and been looking to move a few years ago. The NWSC would a perfect fit and would have kept some good rivalries and with an enrollment of 1800 they are skipping a step in the progression and jumping to the only league that will take them. The only comp I can think of is when Eden Praire exploded.
The EP comp is a good one. I remember them moving from the Metro West Conference to the Lake back in the mid-80s. EP was one of the smaller schools in the conference at the time, and the transition was a bit rough, but it seemed like they were planning for the future with the move.
-
- Posts: 7260
- Joined: Tue Nov 07, 2006 10:28 pm
While the population growth in that area is bordering on explosive, with lots of new young families building homes and moving in, most of the residences you see going up are of the "no frills" variety. Not necessarily 'tract homes', but most of what you see do not shout "wealthy, we can not only afford our home but we also have lots of money to put our kids in expensive off-season travel teams and training, no matter what the cost".kniven wrote:STMA hockey is going to be huge, or is huge already. The next "superpower" in AA Minnesota State High School Hockey.
Then again, perhaps the sheer number of growing young families in the exurbs is the key, and they will find ways to spend what it takes to make their kids competitive with the likes of established programs like Edina, Wayzata, EP, the top privates, etc.
-
- Posts: 508
- Joined: Wed Dec 27, 2017 8:44 am
We thought that about Farmington a few years ago as well. Not saying it never happens (look at Elk River), but the exurbs seem to have a much harder time sustaining success than the middle-outer suburbs.kniven wrote:STMA hockey is going to be huge, or is huge already. The next "superpower" in AA Minnesota State High School Hockey.
-
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2012 9:29 am
- Location: Met Center Press Box
Bloomington went from 1 school to 3 in about 10 years, then closed one, but had 3 for a few years.alcloseshaver wrote:The growth of the STMA school district is hard to keep up with. They probably should have had a little more foresight and been looking to move a few years ago. The NWSC would a perfect fit and would have kept some good rivalries and with an enrollment of 1800 they are skipping a step in the progression and jumping to the only league that will take them. The only comp I can think of is when Eden Praire exploded.
Rochester went from 1 high school with under 1000 kids in ~ 1960 to 2 with a total ~ 3500 in 1975. Not often mentioned but when JM won the state title in 1977 they were one of the largest schools in the state. I believe Rochester still had more kids in grades 10-12 in the 1970's with 2 schools than the have now with 3 schools.....and the population has doubled.
Lakeville and Apple Valley probably fall into this category as well as both came from the Now defunct MissOta (spellchecker won't allow me to spell it correctly ) conference.
-
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Wed Aug 24, 2016 12:23 pm
Elk window of opportunity might have 1-2 more years, then drop off hard. Youth coaching pipeline took a serious hit the last couple years, plus a community that seems to have no interest in replacing the failing ice rinks.ThatMNHockeyGuy62 wrote:We thought that about Farmington a few years ago as well. Not saying it never happens (look at Elk River), but the exurbs seem to have a much harder time sustaining success than the middle-outer suburbs.kniven wrote:STMA hockey is going to be huge, or is huge already. The next "superpower" in AA Minnesota State High School Hockey.
-
- Posts: 6462
- Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2007 9:03 pm
- Contact:
I think this is a key point. History shows pretty clearly that as student populations grow and new suburbs develop, the hockey programs surge. It's quite likely that STMA will continue to be good as it continues to grow, and for some time thereafter. The programs that can sustain themselves beyond the population surge, though, are the ones who are wealthy enough that they won't lose their allure when the housing stock starts to show a little age. (Having a lot of homes on lakes, rivers, and golf courses also helps here.) That's why places like Richfield and the Brooklyns surged and had their moments, but then declined (sometimes into nonexistence) while the likes of Minnetonka and White Bear Lake have stayed relevant. It's not a perfect process, of course, but the broad brush trends aren't hard to see.MNHockeyFan wrote:While the population growth in that area is bordering on explosive, with lots of new young families building homes and moving in, most of the residences you see going up are of the "no frills" variety. Not necessarily 'tract homes', but most of what you see do not shout "wealthy, we can not only afford our home but we also have lots of money to put our kids in expensive off-season travel teams and training, no matter what the cost".kniven wrote:STMA hockey is going to be huge, or is huge already. The next "superpower" in AA Minnesota State High School Hockey.
Then again, perhaps the sheer number of growing young families in the exurbs is the key, and they will find ways to spend what it takes to make their kids competitive with the likes of established programs like Edina, Wayzata, EP, the top privates, etc.
Farmington had a good couple of years but that has been it and that group had been pretty good all along. While Farmington is growing on the Northwest side it is still pretty outstate/rural, probably more akin to Hastings or Owatonna than Lakeville or any other school in its conference. The South Metro schools that have had dominant runs in hockey have also had really good runs in other sports.....Jefferson, Kennedy, Burnsville, Apple Valley, Lakeville. Farmington has not fallen anywhere near that mix yet.ThatMNHockeyGuy62 wrote:We thought that about Farmington a few years ago as well. Not saying it never happens (look at Elk River), but the exurbs seem to have a much harder time sustaining success than the middle-outer suburbs.kniven wrote:STMA hockey is going to be huge, or is huge already. The next "superpower" in AA Minnesota State High School Hockey.
FWIW 5 of the 9 1AA teams still have FFA as a school activity; Farmington, Hastings, Kasson, John Marshall, and Owatonna.
-
- Posts: 508
- Joined: Wed Dec 27, 2017 8:44 am
Agreed. I wasn't trying to compare Farmington to the other schools in its conference, but to STMA. They are both about the same distance from Minneapolis (just a bit further than the likes of Lakeville, Stillwater, Prior Lake, Chaska, Orono, etc). Albertville, Farmington, Waconia, New Prague, etc have all seen housing growth. With that comes a short surge in success, but to say they will be a state power might be a bit premature given their distance from the metro. Only time will tell!goldy313 wrote:Farmington had a good couple of years but that has been it and that group had been pretty good all along. While Farmington is growing on the Northwest side it is still pretty outstate/rural, probably more akin to Hastings or Owatonna than Lakeville or any other school in its conference. The South Metro schools that have had dominant runs in hockey have also had really good runs in other sports.....Jefferson, Kennedy, Burnsville, Apple Valley, Lakeville. Farmington has not fallen anywhere near that mix yet.ThatMNHockeyGuy62 wrote:We thought that about Farmington a few years ago as well. Not saying it never happens (look at Elk River), but the exurbs seem to have a much harder time sustaining success than the middle-outer suburbs.kniven wrote:STMA hockey is going to be huge, or is huge already. The next "superpower" in AA Minnesota State High School Hockey.
FWIW 5 of the 9 1AA teams still have FFA as a school activity; Farmington, Hastings, Kasson, John Marshall, and Owatonna.
-
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2012 9:29 am
- Location: Met Center Press Box
Elk River has a couple rivers but is typically a blue collar bedroom community that has maintained a high level of success for close to 30 years. Will have to work hard to sustain it but not a bad run.karl(east) wrote:I think this is a key point. History shows pretty clearly that as student populations grow and new suburbs develop, the hockey programs surge. It's quite likely that STMA will continue to be good as it continues to grow, and for some time thereafter. The programs that can sustain themselves beyond the population surge, though, are the ones who are wealthy enough that they won't lose their allure when the housing stock starts to show a little age. (Having a lot of homes on lakes, rivers, and golf courses also helps here.) That's why places like Richfield and the Brooklyns surged and had their moments, but then declined (sometimes into nonexistence) while the likes of Minnetonka and White Bear Lake have stayed relevant. It's not a perfect process, of course, but the broad brush trends aren't hard to see.MNHockeyFan wrote:While the population growth in that area is bordering on explosive, with lots of new young families building homes and moving in, most of the residences you see going up are of the "no frills" variety. Not necessarily 'tract homes', but most of what you see do not shout "wealthy, we can not only afford our home but we also have lots of money to put our kids in expensive off-season travel teams and training, no matter what the cost".kniven wrote:STMA hockey is going to be huge, or is huge already. The next "superpower" in AA Minnesota State High School Hockey.
Then again, perhaps the sheer number of growing young families in the exurbs is the key, and they will find ways to spend what it takes to make their kids competitive with the likes of established programs like Edina, Wayzata, EP, the top privates, etc.
-
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2012 9:29 am
- Location: Met Center Press Box
-
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Wed Aug 24, 2016 12:23 pm
If the city of Elk River doesn't figure out how to replace the ice rinks they won't have a hockey program.alcloseshaver wrote:Elk River has a couple rivers but is typically a blue collar bedroom community that has maintained a high level of success for close to 30 years. Will have to work hard to sustain it but not a bad run.karl(east) wrote:I think this is a key point. History shows pretty clearly that as student populations grow and new suburbs develop, the hockey programs surge. It's quite likely that STMA will continue to be good as it continues to grow, and for some time thereafter. The programs that can sustain themselves beyond the population surge, though, are the ones who are wealthy enough that they won't lose their allure when the housing stock starts to show a little age. (Having a lot of homes on lakes, rivers, and golf courses also helps here.) That's why places like Richfield and the Brooklyns surged and had their moments, but then declined (sometimes into nonexistence) while the likes of Minnetonka and White Bear Lake have stayed relevant. It's not a perfect process, of course, but the broad brush trends aren't hard to see.MNHockeyFan wrote: While the population growth in that area is bordering on explosive, with lots of new young families building homes and moving in, most of the residences you see going up are of the "no frills" variety. Not necessarily 'tract homes', but most of what you see do not shout "wealthy, we can not only afford our home but we also have lots of money to put our kids in expensive off-season travel teams and training, no matter what the cost".
Then again, perhaps the sheer number of growing young families in the exurbs is the key, and they will find ways to spend what it takes to make their kids competitive with the likes of established programs like Edina, Wayzata, EP, the top privates, etc.
-
- Posts: 508
- Joined: Wed Dec 27, 2017 8:44 am
I'm guessing since most team's schedules are already finished or mostly finished they will not be starting the conference schedule until 2019/2020?alcloseshaver wrote:STMA joining the Lake conference, it has been agreed upon.
Maple Grove would like to join the Lake also I'm sure but admin won't let them split from from Osseo and PC.
Moorhead ‘s rein of terror is over. STMA is the new boss in 8AA- long term.ThatMNHockeyGuy62 wrote:I'm guessing since most team's schedules are already finished or mostly finished they will not be starting the conference schedule until 2019/2020?alcloseshaver wrote:STMA joining the Lake conference, it has been agreed upon.
Maple Grove would like to join the Lake also I'm sure but admin won't let them split from from Osseo and PC.
-
- Posts: 279
- Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2017 8:58 pm
This just isn’t true. STMA bantams and peewees are simply average. Moorhead is better at every level down to squirts. Projecting out farther than that would be just foolish.kniven wrote:Moorhead ‘s rein of terror is over. STMA is the new boss in 8AA- long term.ThatMNHockeyGuy62 wrote:I'm guessing since most team's schedules are already finished or mostly finished they will not be starting the conference schedule until 2019/2020?alcloseshaver wrote:STMA joining the Lake conference, it has been agreed upon.
Maple Grove would like to join the Lake also I'm sure but admin won't let them split from from Osseo and PC.