I don't think people are disregarding him. He was only a soph this past season and the goalies listed in this thread are seniors.goldy313 wrote: ↑Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:18 am Strange how McCarville is disregarded. He had a bad playoff game against a hot and experienced South team. My guess if Hastings was in 4AA he would be a top 5 goalie but since he is in 1AA he must suck. Go figure the bias here. Alex Kangas is one of the top Gopher goalies, Charlie Lindgren played in the NHL but heck 1AA goalies are inherently bad....
Top 5 Goaltenders
Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
-
- Posts: 241
- Joined: Fri Apr 06, 2018 11:06 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Wonder if Benson will be back with the Bengals this season?
Has there been other times a player went to play tier 1 and then come back to his original HS team for Senior season?
Has there been other times a player went to play tier 1 and then come back to his original HS team for Senior season?
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Hear it's going to be a tough road for Benson to return.. but not impossible...
-
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2018 2:58 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
I know way too much about this BB and Blaine situation. It's ugly, and full of critical comments from a lot of Blaine parents and players that shouldn't get posted due to the facts that these are all kids. However, I have ZERO idea how it ends up.
Blaine's biggest question mark is in goal. This would fix it - or would it?
Leave high school after sophomore year - play tier 1 junior year- sign a NAHL tender - back to your high school for your senior year
Blaine's biggest question mark is in goal. This would fix it - or would it?
Leave high school after sophomore year - play tier 1 junior year- sign a NAHL tender - back to your high school for your senior year
-
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2018 2:58 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Could very well be!InThePipes wrote: ↑Sun Jul 28, 2019 8:02 amI'm hearing rumblings that suggest his roster spot may be "real"?612hockeytown wrote: ↑Wed Jul 17, 2019 1:59 amHe might be rostered - he will be fighting Jake Begley (2nd rd draft pick this year, 2 years of USHL experience and fighting for a D1 spot in his last year of junior eligibility) and Brandon Benson (Blaine HS/ Sioux Falls power u16- tendered mid-season). If all 3 indeed are there and rostered - I’d give the edge to the latter 2.
NAHL teams always stack the goalies. The Magicians had Haider, Robbel, Mitchell James and Conan Hayton to start the season. The latter 2 played a combined 2 games (James played both while Robbel was injured). Both were cut when Robbel returned. Juniors is a tough deal.
-
- Posts: 1008
- Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2012 8:26 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
An atypical path (if that's how plays out) no doubt about that!612hockeytown wrote: ↑Tue Aug 27, 2019 12:12 am I know way too much about this BB and Blaine situation. It's ugly, and full of critical comments from a lot of Blaine parents and players that shouldn't get posted due to the facts that these are all kids. However, I have ZERO idea how it ends up.
Blaine's biggest question mark is in goal. This would fix it - or would it?
Leave high school after sophomore year - play tier 1 junior year- sign a NAHL tender - back to your high school for your senior year
I had heard rumblings of this after word broke that Johnson was in the mix at Lone Star, I haven't heard any specifics behind how this all unfolded or what came first in the string of events that have led to this point.
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
I heard there is still some question around if BB will be allowed back, but then again... all rumors and such...
-
- Posts: 1008
- Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2012 8:26 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
I'm trying to understand how he wouldn't be allowed back though? I assume his parents still live in the school district (or he individually moved back in this summer, if that matters). He didn't go play for another MSHSL team, he went out of state and played T1. I'm no MSHSL eligibility expert, so I definitely could be missing something.
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Depends on " school of attendance "....
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
From the discussion above, I am gathering that it is not so much an eligibility issue, but more like whether the team wants him back after leaving.InThePipes wrote: ↑Tue Aug 27, 2019 8:31 amI'm trying to understand how he wouldn't be allowed back though? I assume his parents still live in the school district (or he individually moved back in this summer, if that matters). He didn't go play for another MSHSL team, he went out of state and played T1. I'm no MSHSL eligibility expert, so I definitely could be missing something.
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Top 2019-20 goalie stats from HSEL site as of tonight. Note- Hogg is playing for Blades
945 SAVE %
Carson Limesand
#30 GOALIE
SIT Mutual Funds
Hudson Hodges#30 Power .933
Austin Cooley#30 Corner Ho .922
Remington Keopple#30 Team Wisc .921
Zach Hayes#1 Twin Citi .919
Josh Weyandt#30 TDS Trans .913
Will Tollefson#1 TDS Trans .906
Dominik Caspers#1 SIT Mutual .904
Noah Rupprecht#1 Power .895
Derek Manzella#1 MPLS St. .891
945 SAVE %
Carson Limesand
#30 GOALIE
SIT Mutual Funds
Hudson Hodges#30 Power .933
Austin Cooley#30 Corner Ho .922
Remington Keopple#30 Team Wisc .921
Zach Hayes#1 Twin Citi .919
Josh Weyandt#30 TDS Trans .913
Will Tollefson#1 TDS Trans .906
Dominik Caspers#1 SIT Mutual .904
Noah Rupprecht#1 Power .895
Derek Manzella#1 MPLS St. .891
-
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2018 2:58 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Johnson no longer rostered on LS. Any idea where he went?InThePipes wrote: ↑Tue Jul 16, 2019 11:10 amStang5280 wrote: ↑Sun Jul 14, 2019 12:35 pmSure, but I also think you have to account for the fact that two of the top goaltenders – Fritsinger and Mueller – have decided not to continue playing beyond high school. Both likely would have ended up on junior rosters had they chosen to pursue that route.InThePipes wrote: ↑Sat Jul 13, 2019 10:31 pm
I'm going to guess that Glockner and Welch will ultimately land somewhere as well, but you are correct that there were some very "interesting" selections last year. There are obviously times when there is more to the story behind the scenes that provides additional explanation, but I still haven't heard anything.
Will Johnson from LVN to Lone Star Brahmas
Also Nathan Mueller to the Wisconsin Lumberjacks of the SIJHL.
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
612- I struck out with several sources on your
Will Johnson question. Must be some Lvn forum people out there who know?
Will Johnson question. Must be some Lvn forum people out there who know?
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
DiLaura traded to Portland
-
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2018 2:58 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Thanks WM.
Also big trade for Portland. DiLaura going to the best organization in the Dub. Hope he can find some success there.
Also big trade for Portland. DiLaura going to the best organization in the Dub. Hope he can find some success there.
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Went up to Showcase hoping to see Jon Howe in a rotating start tonight for Jamestown against Magicians , but they kept their No. 1 goalie starting again tonite. Lost 2-1 , magicians scored with 4 sec left. Cant make it tomorrow against Kenai, if anyone goes and he starts, please give us an update. Although I guess its getting time to bury these post HS goalie comments.
I will say, within the proper use of the HS Forum, that Oberle was one of the more dominant players on the ice.
I will say, within the proper use of the HS Forum, that Oberle was one of the more dominant players on the ice.
-
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2018 2:58 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Sounds like if things go to plan - West will play 66-75% of the games. They don’t care too much about the location and it being a “home” game for a lot of Minnesota kids and their families here to watch them. I’d be shocked if they don’t play Howe at least once though. I figure their starter West plays 3 of 4. Jamestown isn’t as strong as they were last year.
Caught the Magician / Rebels game on hockey tv. If Laylin goes back to STMA - the Magic will lose a huge scoring punch. I think they’ll struggle to score goals this season. Hale will have to step up, as will a lot of their newcomers. They’ll miss Keranen, Buhl, Kruse, and the 1-2 punch of Haider / Robbel. Former SSM goalie David Tomeo (New Jersey) was a nice, late addition. Played well today.
Caught the Magician / Rebels game on hockey tv. If Laylin goes back to STMA - the Magic will lose a huge scoring punch. I think they’ll struggle to score goals this season. Hale will have to step up, as will a lot of their newcomers. They’ll miss Keranen, Buhl, Kruse, and the 1-2 punch of Haider / Robbel. Former SSM goalie David Tomeo (New Jersey) was a nice, late addition. Played well today.
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Yeah, couldnt help but have questionmark in my mind about Hales future at UMd.
Far as I know, both Laylin and Oberle will be back at HS, but until November rolls around nothing is certain anymore.
Far as I know, both Laylin and Oberle will be back at HS, but until November rolls around nothing is certain anymore.
-
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2018 2:58 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
As far as I know - Hale won’t be at UMD or at least he isn’t in their plans. Only have that from a secondary source close to the school (and who’s kid is currently committed there). He did remove the commitment off one of his social media accounts
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Agree with you 612
“As far as I know - Hale won’t be at UMD or at least he isn’t in their plans”
But Sandy probably reluctant to officially pull a commit ? so ball in Jakes court ?
UMD is still on his Twitter account.
“As far as I know - Hale won’t be at UMD or at least he isn’t in their plans”
But Sandy probably reluctant to officially pull a commit ? so ball in Jakes court ?
UMD is still on his Twitter account.
-
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2018 2:58 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
WestMetro wrote: ↑Thu Sep 19, 2019 8:42 pm Went up to Showcase hoping to see Jon Howe in a rotating start tonight for Jamestown against Magicians , but they kept their No. 1 goalie starting again tonite. Lost 2-1 , magicians scored with 4 sec left. Cant make it tomorrow against Kenai, if anyone goes and he starts, please give us an update. Although I guess its getting time to bury these post HS goalie comments.
I will say, within the proper use of the HS Forum, that Oberle was one of the more dominant players on the ice.
https://twitter.com/nahlhockey/status/1 ... 30016?s=21
Oberle and partner will have to better than that to be successful! I see dad in the stands was none too happy. The NAHL isn’t high school. Physical play is a must. Tough loss for the Magic today. I see Howe got the start against Kenai River today. In progress...
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Elite League Stats Thru Oct 13 from its website
940 SAVE %Carsen Stokes#30 GOALIEShattuck-St. Mary's .940
#30 Carson Limesand SIT Mutual .939 (thru 5 games)
#30 Hudson Hodges Sanford .932
#1 Dominik Caspers SIT Mutual .918
#30 Remington Keopple Team Wisc .917
#1 Derek Manzella MPLS St. .911
#30 William Pinney Twin Citi .901
#1 Zach Hayes Twin Citi .901
#30 Austin Cooley Corner Ho .899
#30 Josh Weyandt TDS Trans .896
Noel Rupprecht .891
Carter Clafton .890
In terms of spring 2019 graduates, I saw that Glockner and Howe are both over 90% saves in NAHL with 4 full or partial games played. Dont know Boynton status, limited ice time at Fargo so far?
940 SAVE %Carsen Stokes#30 GOALIEShattuck-St. Mary's .940
#30 Carson Limesand SIT Mutual .939 (thru 5 games)
#30 Hudson Hodges Sanford .932
#1 Dominik Caspers SIT Mutual .918
#30 Remington Keopple Team Wisc .917
#1 Derek Manzella MPLS St. .911
#30 William Pinney Twin Citi .901
#1 Zach Hayes Twin Citi .901
#30 Austin Cooley Corner Ho .899
#30 Josh Weyandt TDS Trans .896
Noel Rupprecht .891
Carter Clafton .890
In terms of spring 2019 graduates, I saw that Glockner and Howe are both over 90% saves in NAHL with 4 full or partial games played. Dont know Boynton status, limited ice time at Fargo so far?
-
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2018 2:58 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Boynton won't see a ton of ice time in Fargo. It's Brady's net. Jake Sibell played a similar role in Sioux City last year. Played 20 games last year behind Ben Kraws and left there to play in the NAHL this year. Sioux City drafted Haider 3rd overall and had Aidan Harper as well. Haider has played all 6 games so far. Jake made the right choice and is currently playing for Aberdeen. He played well in the showcase, notching a shutout, after a rough first game.WestMetro wrote: ↑Mon Oct 14, 2019 9:55 am Elite League Stats Thru Oct 13 from its website
940 SAVE %Carsen Stokes#30 GOALIEShattuck-St. Mary's .940
#30 Carson Limesand SIT Mutual .939 (thru 5 games)
#30 Hudson Hodges Sanford .932
#1 Dominik Caspers SIT Mutual .918
#30 Remington Keopple Team Wisc .917
#1 Derek Manzella MPLS St. .911
#30 William Pinney Twin Citi .901
#1 Zach Hayes Twin Citi .901
#30 Austin Cooley Corner Ho .899
#30 Josh Weyandt TDS Trans .896
Noel Rupprecht .891
Carter Clafton .890
In terms of spring 2019 graduates, I saw that Glockner and Howe are both over 90% saves in NAHL with 4 full or partial games played. Dont know Boynton status, limited ice time at Fargo so far?
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
2019 Tonka system/ Totino grads NAHL goalies are doing great. Glockner was NAHL recent star of the week in the South Division, and Howe was 2nd star of the week in the East. Both are at about 92% save percentage.
-
- Posts: 1008
- Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2012 8:26 pm
Re: Top 5 Goaltenders
Great for them and several former MNHS goalies appear to be thriving in the NA