Edina Invitational Tournament- Peewee A scores/etc...

Discussion of Minnesota Youth Hockey

Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)

Snowmass
Posts: 206
Joined: Wed Feb 11, 2009 3:28 pm

Edina Invitational Tournament- Peewee A scores/etc...

Post by Snowmass »

December 30th- Jan 2nd. Peewee A
Pool A- Edina, Elk River, Lakeville, Roseau
Pool B- Eden Prairie, Wayzata, Centennial, Mpls. Park
Pool C- Chaska, Osseo/MG, STMA, Farm
HockeyStorm
Posts: 157
Joined: Fri Oct 03, 2008 10:42 pm

Post by HockeyStorm »

I like ER in Pool A, EP in B, Farmington in C, and Edina as the wild card.
InigoMontoya
Posts: 1716
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2009 12:36 pm

Post by InigoMontoya »

The defending peewee A state champs and defending peewee B champs and runner-ups are the wild card.
old goalie85
Posts: 3696
Joined: Wed Feb 25, 2009 6:37 pm

Post by old goalie85 »

Farmington, ST.michael ...
Night Train
Posts: 350
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007 1:16 pm

Post by Night Train »

Pool B- Eden Prairie, Wayzata, Centennial, Mpls. Park
Probaly Minneapolis as the only Mpls-Park team is Bantam A.
codemanh
Posts: 197
Joined: Wed Feb 03, 2010 4:43 pm

Re: Edina Invitational Tournament- Peewee A scores/etc...

Post by codemanh »

Snowmass wrote:December 30th- Jan 2nd. Peewee A
Pool A- Edina, Elk River, Lakeville, Roseau
Pool B- Eden Prairie, Wayzata, Centennial, Mpls. Park
Pool C- Chaska, Osseo/MG, STMA, Farm
I like ER out of A, Centennial out of B, and Farmington out of C
HockeyGuy81
Posts: 220
Joined: Tue Feb 03, 2009 1:09 pm

Post by HockeyGuy81 »

Night Train wrote:
Pool B- Eden Prairie, Wayzata, Centennial, Mpls. Park
Probaly Minneapolis as the only Mpls-Park team is Bantam A.
No one cares about the semantics, just picking teams out of the pools.
pedrosnchz81
Posts: 30
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2010 8:28 am

Post by pedrosnchz81 »

Wayzata 10
Centennial 1

EP 7
Mpls 3

STMA 2
Maple Grove 2

Farmington 5
Chaska 0

Edina beat Roseau

Elk River beat Lakeville South
Snowmass
Posts: 206
Joined: Wed Feb 11, 2009 3:28 pm

Post by Snowmass »

Day 1 went pretty much as expected. Edina and Wayzata rolled, EP had hands full for a while with Mpls before winning 7-3. Maple grove had a nice come back to tie STMA. Ties always throw wrenches into pool play tourneys. Farmington won fairly handily over Chaska.
Toomuchtoosoon
Posts: 267
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2008 4:46 pm

Post by Toomuchtoosoon »

for $25 a parent, you would think they could spend a few minutes and update the scores for all the divisions in a timely manner. Too busy counting the money I guess.
Snowmass
Posts: 206
Joined: Wed Feb 11, 2009 3:28 pm

Post by Snowmass »

Toomuchtoosoon wrote:for $25 a parent, you would think they could spend a few minutes and update the scores for all the divisions in a timely manner. Too busy counting the money I guess.
I hear ya on the $25/per person for the weekend pass ($5/per game if your make it) And the updated scores is awesome when it's actually done. Not to defend the pricing, but here I go: most tournaments charge roughly the same at the end of the day I'd argue. Be it team fee, or gate fee or program fee or concessions it all is basically the same in the end. Dishing out cash to see my 12 yr old play after all other season costs..........well it sucks. But it is what it is....year after year. Either accept it or move on.
ThePuckStopsHere
Posts: 418
Joined: Fri Feb 06, 2009 12:09 pm

Post by ThePuckStopsHere »

Snowmass wrote:
Toomuchtoosoon wrote:for $25 a parent, you would think they could spend a few minutes and update the scores for all the divisions in a timely manner. Too busy counting the money I guess.
I hear ya on the $25/per person for the weekend pass ($5/per game if your make it) And the updated scores is awesome when it's actually done. Not to defend the pricing, but here I go: most tournaments charge roughly the same at the end of the day I'd argue. Be it team fee, or gate fee or program fee or concessions it all is basically the same in the end. Dishing out cash to see my 12 yr old play after all other season costs..........well it sucks. But it is what it is....year after year. Either accept it or move on.
Totally disagree, most tournaments charge a $250.00 gate fee. On a 17 player roster that is $14.70 per player and that covers any person that wants to come and watch that player.

Edina is charging $25.00 per person, on a 17 player team with say 2 parents that attend the tournament that = $850.00 and that is figuring very low. So they are charging at least 3 times more than other tournaments.

I for one had to shell out $75.00 yesterday. Everyone I saw coming in was pissed at the gate, if you want to call it what it is, it's Edina overcharging and taking advantage of their customer's. Just another reason to hate Edina :wink:
Toomuchtoosoon
Posts: 267
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2008 4:46 pm

Post by Toomuchtoosoon »

But it is what it is....year after year. Either accept it or move on.
Missed the point-if you run a first class tourney, then update the scores in a timely manner as you advertised.

I actually like all the money coming into Edina :D
Snowmass
Posts: 206
Joined: Wed Feb 11, 2009 3:28 pm

Post by Snowmass »

ThePuckStopsHere wrote:
Snowmass wrote:
Toomuchtoosoon wrote:for $25 a parent, you would think they could spend a few minutes and update the scores for all the divisions in a timely manner. Too busy counting the money I guess.
I hear ya on the $25/per person for the weekend pass ($5/per game if your make it) And the updated scores is awesome when it's actually done. Not to defend the pricing, but here I go: most tournaments charge roughly the same at the end of the day I'd argue. Be it team fee, or gate fee or program fee or concessions it all is basically the same in the end. Dishing out cash to see my 12 yr old play after all other season costs..........well it sucks. But it is what it is....year after year. Either accept it or move on.
Totally disagree, most tournaments charge a $250.00 gate fee. On a 17 player roster that is $14.70 per player and that covers any person that wants to come and watch that player.

Edina is charging $25.00 per person, on a 17 player team with say 2 parents that attend the tournament that = $850.00 and that is figuring very low. So they are charging at least 3 times more than other tournaments.

I for one had to shell out $75.00 yesterday. Everyone I saw coming in was pissed at the gate, if you want to call it what it is, it's Edina overcharging and taking advantage of their customer's. Just another reason to hate Edina :wink:
Fair enough. I guess i didn't do the full analysis/breakdown. If that is so, then it's lame.
MrBoDangles
Posts: 4090
Joined: Tue Jan 27, 2009 9:32 pm

Post by MrBoDangles »

ThePuckStopsHere wrote:
Snowmass wrote:
Toomuchtoosoon wrote:for $25 a parent, you would think they could spend a few minutes and update the scores for all the divisions in a timely manner. Too busy counting the money I guess.
I hear ya on the $25/per person for the weekend pass ($5/per game if your make it) And the updated scores is awesome when it's actually done. Not to defend the pricing, but here I go: most tournaments charge roughly the same at the end of the day I'd argue. Be it team fee, or gate fee or program fee or concessions it all is basically the same in the end. Dishing out cash to see my 12 yr old play after all other season costs..........well it sucks. But it is what it is....year after year. Either accept it or move on.
Totally disagree, most tournaments charge a $250.00 gate fee. On a 17 player roster that is $14.70 per player and that covers any person that wants to come and watch that player.

Edina is charging $25.00 per person, on a 17 player team with say 2 parents that attend the tournament that = $850.00 and that is figuring very low. So they are charging at least 3 times more than other tournaments.

I for one had to shell out $75.00 yesterday. Everyone I saw coming in was pissed at the gate, if you want to call it what it is, it's Edina overcharging and taking advantage of their customer's. Just another reason to hate Edina :wink:
Didn't you see the cake and champagne inside? :wink:
Towelie
Posts: 78
Joined: Thu Dec 16, 2010 12:12 pm

Post by Towelie »

Toomuchtoosoon wrote:
But it is what it is....year after year. Either accept it or move on.
Missed the point-if you run a first class tourney, then update the scores in a timely manner as you advertised.

Pretty sure their website states the following:

"Scoring updates are provided throughout the tournament weekend by the Edina Hockey Association"

Please can you point out the part that says after each game, every second, by the hour .....etc......etc...

If you need a towel to wipe those tears away let me know I have plenty.
Did somebody say they needed a Towel ??
InigoMontoya
Posts: 1716
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2009 12:36 pm

Post by InigoMontoya »

Towelie wrote:
Toomuchtoosoon wrote:
But it is what it is....year after year. Either accept it or move on.
Missed the point-if you run a first class tourney, then update the scores in a timely manner as you advertised.

Pretty sure their website states the following:

"Scoring updates are provided throughout the tournament weekend by the Edina Hockey Association"

Please can you point out the part that says after each game, every second, by the hour .....etc......etc...

If you need a towel to wipe those tears away let me know I have plenty.
At $25, they should have a hot mite mom escort me to my seat and ask if I'd like her to blow on my hot chocolate.
hockey_is_a_choice
Posts: 239
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2008 10:48 am

Post by hockey_is_a_choice »

Instead of complaining about Edina maximizing its profits by charging each parent a $25 gate fee, every association should agree to charge Edina parents a $25 gate fee when the Hornets partcipate in tournaments outside Edina. Other associations' parents would be charged a lower gate fee. Turnabout is fair play . . .
HockeyGuy81
Posts: 220
Joined: Tue Feb 03, 2009 1:09 pm

Post by HockeyGuy81 »

What I'm completely shocked by is that this entire discussion has gotten off topic. That never happens on here. Maybe 2011 will be different (not a chance)
InigoMontoya
Posts: 1716
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2009 12:36 pm

Post by InigoMontoya »

HockeyGuy81 wrote:What I'm completely shocked by is that this entire discussion has gotten off topic. That never happens on here. Maybe 2011 will be different (not a chance)
In fairness, the topic does include "/etc..."
observer
Posts: 2225
Joined: Wed Apr 02, 2008 8:45 pm

Post by observer »

hockeyover40
Posts: 109
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2008 10:04 pm

Post by hockeyover40 »

They're doing a nice job. Don't even have Fridays scores up yet.
seek & destroy
Posts: 328
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2008 2:38 pm

Post by seek & destroy »

ThePuckStopsHere wrote:
Snowmass wrote:
Toomuchtoosoon wrote:for $25 a parent, you would think they could spend a few minutes and update the scores for all the divisions in a timely manner. Too busy counting the money I guess.
I hear ya on the $25/per person for the weekend pass ($5/per game if your make it) And the updated scores is awesome when it's actually done. Not to defend the pricing, but here I go: most tournaments charge roughly the same at the end of the day I'd argue. Be it team fee, or gate fee or program fee or concessions it all is basically the same in the end. Dishing out cash to see my 12 yr old play after all other season costs..........well it sucks. But it is what it is....year after year. Either accept it or move on.
Totally disagree, most tournaments charge a $250.00 gate fee. On a 17 player roster that is $14.70 per player and that covers any person that wants to come and watch that player.

Edina is charging $25.00 per person, on a 17 player team with say 2 parents that attend the tournament that = $850.00 and that is figuring very low. So they are charging at least 3 times more than other tournaments.

I for one had to shell out $75.00 yesterday. Everyone I saw coming in was pissed at the gate, if you want to call it what it is, it's Edina overcharging and taking advantage of their customer's. Just another reason to hate Edina :wink:
Not to go 'hatin' on Edina but the entry fee was not a low one either. Usually if you are going to charge a heavy gate fee, the entry fee is low. Their fee was $725 per team. Add to that the gate charges and I could see where some people would be upset.

Also, for a holiday weekend tournament you quite often have a lot of friends and family that are around and would like to come watch the games so I agree that the $850 estimate is very low. They are making a killing on this tourney! And to the original question...why would they update the site with current scores? This way people have to come pay the gate to find out what is going on.
buttend
Posts: 374
Joined: Sun Feb 03, 2008 9:53 pm

Post by buttend »

seek & destroy wrote: Also, for a holiday weekend tournament you quite often have a lot of friends and family that are around and would like to come watch the games so I agree that the $850 estimate is very low. They are making a killing on this tourney! And to the original question...why would they update the site with current scores? This way people have to come pay the gate to find out what is going on.
This tourney has 5 levels, 58 teams and 110 games scheduled. I estimate that each game will cost about $400. 1.33 hr ice at $187 per hour. $78 for 2 refs. ( 3 refs and 1.5 hours of ice at the BTM level) 1 EMT. 110 x $400 = is roughly $44K. 58 teams x $725 entry fee is $42K. At best this tourney is even without the gate fee. BTW the Bloomington tourney charged a $20 per person fee.

Tournaments are fundraisers for Associations. If you feel a specific tournament/Association is "taking advantage of parents and the situation" the best thing to do is not sign up for their events.
seek & destroy
Posts: 328
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2008 2:38 pm

Post by seek & destroy »

buttend wrote:
seek & destroy wrote: Also, for a holiday weekend tournament you quite often have a lot of friends and family that are around and would like to come watch the games so I agree that the $850 estimate is very low. They are making a killing on this tourney! And to the original question...why would they update the site with current scores? This way people have to come pay the gate to find out what is going on.
This tourney has 5 levels, 58 teams and 110 games scheduled. I estimate that each game will cost about $400. 1.33 hr ice at $187 per hour. $78 for 2 refs. ( 3 refs and 1.5 hours of ice at the BTM level) 1 EMT. 110 x $400 = is roughly $44K. 58 teams x $725 entry fee is $42K. At best this tourney is even without the gate fee. BTW the Bloomington tourney charged a $20 per person fee.

Tournaments are fundraisers for Associations. If you feel a specific tournament/Association is "taking advantage of parents and the situation" the best thing to do is not sign up for their events.
With 58 teams and a likely average gate of $850 per team (2 people per player @ $25 ea X 17 players - not including grandma and grandpa) you have revenue of around $50,000. That's a lot for a youth hockey tournament. Also, you are right about not signing up for the events but a lot of times the parents, grandparents and players have no say in the tournaments scheduled - it is determined by the coach or the association board prior to the season starting.
Post Reply