AA Rankings for 2/13/11
Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)
I think I need to add my $.02 about AHA, some have probably been waiting.
All the conference teams are tired of AHA beating them by 6 - 10 goals over the last ten years. I would be too. Some of the goalies who are seniors have been that way for the last four years. Let's face it, most of the conference teams would do most anything to beat AHA, the goalies have been playing them pretty tough. Even some of the parents have said that the goalies have never played this good.
I give the conference teams a a lot of credit for "getting charged up" to play AHA. This will help AHA in the long run. Most people on this board only see the scores and not the way teams play them.
I am hoping that AHA gets the 2 seed, but in my opinion they will get 3 or 4. So what, you have to win three games in the section to move on, everyone does. I still think they will step up their game and win the section. But they will need to play either Chanhassen or Shakopee first, and that will be tough.
We will see......see you all in a week
All the conference teams are tired of AHA beating them by 6 - 10 goals over the last ten years. I would be too. Some of the goalies who are seniors have been that way for the last four years. Let's face it, most of the conference teams would do most anything to beat AHA, the goalies have been playing them pretty tough. Even some of the parents have said that the goalies have never played this good.
I give the conference teams a a lot of credit for "getting charged up" to play AHA. This will help AHA in the long run. Most people on this board only see the scores and not the way teams play them.
I am hoping that AHA gets the 2 seed, but in my opinion they will get 3 or 4. So what, you have to win three games in the section to move on, everyone does. I still think they will step up their game and win the section. But they will need to play either Chanhassen or Shakopee first, and that will be tough.
We will see......see you all in a week
-
- Posts: 6480
- Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2007 9:03 pm
- Contact:
Re: AHA
You won't ever find me holding a team back in the rankings because they run up scores. That's an ethical issue that has absolutely no bearing on rankings. (Past a certain number of goals, I just stop caring about the score.) Your use of "people" there is very broad.HShockeywatcher wrote:When teams do well in conference play they are called for running up the score, then when they play close games, the team is in question. I would guess that when Holy Angels, or Hill, plays a close conference game they are mixing up lines, playing back up goalie, etc. Yes, they had a bad loss recently, but so did a (top) team they played recently.
My opinion is that they started slow, had a couple things to sort out, got them sorted out, showed they can play by beating a top 3 team and playing others close. Oh well.
If they were only beating conference opponents by 5 goals instead of 10, I'd buy the "just messing with lines and such" argument. And when a team's game with Chanhassen goes to OT, I doubt they're messing around with lines by the end. If AHA were really a dominant force, they'd be winning these games without any worry. Period. It's not that the scores are a little closer than usual; many of the games' final scores are actually in doubt.
If we look at the scores from AHA's first meetings with Missota teams and compare them to the second meetings, they do not suggest they have "sorted things out." Instead, there's a lot of consistency, and very similar scores between the two rounds.
Last edited by karl(east) on Sun Feb 13, 2011 11:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 632
- Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 8:26 pm
-
- Posts: 76
- Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2010 11:57 pm
Re: AA Rankings for 2/13/11
I agree with this that BSM should be one spot higher than tonka since they had beaten them. However I can see where you stand as tonka has tied Ep and murdered wayzata. HM should be 2 at best also. I mean EP has done a lot better this year, losing to better teams and also beating HM, but that edina loss makes me question them, but as one goes in depth, this year is just way to ridiculous to even try and rank a team, so props to you karl on another fantastic jobHShockeywatcher wrote:-I'd have Benilde one spot higher, as they beat the team above them.
I think it's odd to say the #1 team can be the #1 team while losing to the #7 and #10 teams in the first 3 games, but say a team can't be top 15 because of first 3 game losses, despite the wins and close losses they do have. Oh well, we can continue to agree to disagree![]()

The Greatness is always the Best
Re: AA Rankings for 2/13/11
EP has lost to Edina twice this season. 12/18 (3-2) and 02/03 (3-0)The Greatness wrote:I agree with this that BSM should be one spot higher than tonka since they had beaten them. However I can see where you stand as tonka has tied Ep and murdered wayzata. HM should be 2 at best also. I mean EP has done a lot better this year, losing to better teams and also beating HM, but that edina loss makes me question them, but as one goes in depth, this year is just way to ridiculous to even try and rank a team, so props to you karl on another fantastic jobHShockeywatcher wrote:-I'd have Benilde one spot higher, as they beat the team above them.
I think it's odd to say the #1 team can be the #1 team while losing to the #7 and #10 teams in the first 3 games, but say a team can't be top 15 because of first 3 game losses, despite the wins and close losses they do have. Oh well, we can continue to agree to disagree![]()
EP and Edina meet for the third time this Saturday (02/19) at Edina.

The Puck
LGW
LGW
-
- Posts: 67
- Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2011 1:21 pm
-
- Posts: 76
- Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2010 11:57 pm
Re: AA Rankings for 2/13/11
Thanks for that man. yes well those 2 losses make me question them even more! That will be a fantastic game. Lets see if edina can have a ep sweep.PuckU126 wrote:EP has lost to Edina twice this season. 12/18 (3-2) and 02/03 (3-0)The Greatness wrote:I agree with this that BSM should be one spot higher than tonka since they had beaten them. However I can see where you stand as tonka has tied Ep and murdered wayzata. HM should be 2 at best also. I mean EP has done a lot better this year, losing to better teams and also beating HM, but that edina loss makes me question them, but as one goes in depth, this year is just way to ridiculous to even try and rank a team, so props to you karl on another fantastic jobHShockeywatcher wrote:-I'd have Benilde one spot higher, as they beat the team above them.
I think it's odd to say the #1 team can be the #1 team while losing to the #7 and #10 teams in the first 3 games, but say a team can't be top 15 because of first 3 game losses, despite the wins and close losses they do have. Oh well, we can continue to agree to disagree![]()
EP and Edina meet for the third time this Saturday (02/19) at Edina.
The Greatness is always the Best
Re: AA Rankings for 2/13/11
You're welcome.The Greatness wrote:Thanks for that man. yes well those 2 losses make me question them even more! That will be a fantastic game. Lets see if edina can have a ep sweep.PuckU126 wrote:EP has lost to Edina twice this season. 12/18 (3-2) and 02/03 (3-0)The Greatness wrote: I agree with this that BSM should be one spot higher than tonka since they had beaten them. However I can see where you stand as tonka has tied Ep and murdered wayzata. HM should be 2 at best also. I mean EP has done a lot better this year, losing to better teams and also beating HM, but that edina loss makes me question them, but as one goes in depth, this year is just way to ridiculous to even try and rank a team, so props to you karl on another fantastic job
EP and Edina meet for the third time this Saturday (02/19) at Edina.
And it will be tough to get the sweep against EP; taking into account Everson will not be playing.
Regardless, it will be a great game.

The Puck
LGW
LGW
-
- Posts: 76
- Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2010 11:57 pm
Re: AA Rankings for 2/13/11
Agree. But just like last time it will depend on how the goalies play with Girard coming out on top and ford playing good but not perfect. Everson out will put a lot more on Girard and Rau will hopefully capitalize on this.PuckU126 wrote:You're welcome.The Greatness wrote:Thanks for that man. yes well those 2 losses make me question them even more! That will be a fantastic game. Lets see if edina can have a ep sweep.PuckU126 wrote: EP has lost to Edina twice this season. 12/18 (3-2) and 02/03 (3-0)
EP and Edina meet for the third time this Saturday (02/19) at Edina.
And it will be tough to get the sweep against EP; taking into account Everson will not be playing.
Regardless, it will be a great game.
The Greatness is always the Best
Re: AA Rankings for 2/13/11
You've got that right, Greatness.The Greatness wrote:Agree. But just like last time it will depend on how the goalies play with Girard coming out on top and ford playing good but not perfect. Everson out will put a lot more on Girard and Rau will hopefully capitalize on this.

The Puck
LGW
LGW